Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.2k Topics 133.0k Posts
  • Fuel for the Zionist dream of ruling the world?

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    41 Views
    T
    A bigger tribe? Possibly -- a tribe of vassals with the Zionists lording over them. It appears to be a long-suffering dream of theirs. The ahistorical Bible's militant injunctions and fancy promises allow a religious flavor to the Zionist aspirations. Remove these mythical elements and what pretext would the Zionists have? I think a Zionist is likely to be one rooted in Judaism or Christianity (at least in as much as it can help their cause). But at a more general level, any Jew or Christian who would endorse the above diktats might be a good candidate. I don't think it's only about land, it's about kingdom. Who do you think are the Zionists, and what do you suppose is their goal? I hope the Jews, Christians and others who have been led to believe (due to brainwashing or simply want of better knowledge) that terrorism is another name for the Quran would open their eyes (and the two books) and see for themselves which of the two is a terrorist manual. And what about Noah and the ship?
  • Are Quranists The People Of The Book ?

    8
    0 Votes
    8 Posts
    49 Views
    P
    Well I know people of the the book can have ALOT of meanings. But if not taken in context to mean 'people of this book' it seems that it only refers to people who adhere to the Torah, i.e. Mosaic teachings. . This definition is from Al-Qamus and is the same one to be found in Lisan al-arab. Although I will double check it's synonymous use with katibah, both possibly meaning divine scripts. If the prhase means 'people of revelation from above' that is something else, but it also can specifically mean 'People of the Mosaic teaching'. The references to the Bible in lane seem to come from Tafsirs only. Godbless, Anwar
  • modesty in quran

    36
    0 Votes
    36 Posts
    345 Views
    B
    but if you hide the minimum from the outside world and say that the ornaments or adornments are private parts then the verse says that you are permitted to display these to your father, brother, son etc... which doesn't seem right, so more area must be covered in order for it to make sense that you can uncover those parts in front of certain people. eg in traditional islam, the hair is covered in front of non mahram but can be revealed to mahrams. so what are the limits in qur'an because to cover the private parts only in front of non mahram would mean being free to reveal them in front of mahram. so what do you think are the limits? Well I think every individual has their own limits. For example, I feel comfortable wearing singlets/tank top and shorts AT HOME where no body but my family or really close relatives is around. But when I go outside, the minimum will be T-shirt and jeans.
  • can you scientifically prove there's only one God?

    55
    0 Votes
    55 Posts
    312 Views
    R
    I guess this is a little abstract...perhaps simple or ambiguous...but I see it this way... People say to me... "you mean to tell me Allah (God) is Eternal? that doesn't make sense. Thats Dogmatic! how can something be Before the Before...and After the After...? IMPOSSIBLE...NOTHING is Constant and NOTHING is Infinite! LIAR!"" So My reply is that Allah God is the Greatest Mathematician. He Created the entire Universe and All and he is Eternal (before the before/After the after), I say to them that HE created Good and Created bad, and Created the Universe in Many Ways... Literally,(Physically)...Symbolically(Spiritually)...and in many languages... The UNIVERSAL language is MATH. Therefore hence when you see a Snow Crystal...it is a Physical thing...bound by Physical Laws of Physics and Science... But also a Spiritual thing which effects your Spirit (water compounds) and It is Represented in Numbers also... I look at life in two ways... Physical... and Also Mathematical... Think about the Matrix the movie as a Visual... in One Part Neo is a Mad with Black Sunglasses...Then the Screen Changes...and neo is a bunch of Green Numbers adding up on a Black Background. So Neo is both a Physical person...and also Translation; a Number pattern. Or watch the movie Pi and you'll understand that Numbers and patterns are in the universe around. The Books "Torah" "Ingil" and "Quran" all are composed of Number Sequences... Then Ill explain the Eternal Part.... Numbers Are Eternal.... They Go from ....to infinity.......-5,-4,-3,-2-1, 0, 1,2,3,4,5.......To infinity. You can see that in an essence... Numbers are eternal... Before the before...after the after.... Now, I am NOT saying Numbers are God... That is Shirk. ALLAH AKBAR... All I am doing is illustrating that I believe ALLAh who is "The Source" Communicated in a Number of ways..... Through the use of Numbers. And if this Simple Communication (Numbers) is the ONLY example we can think of Physically that is Eternal... Then we can establish a fact that...Allah (The Creator) is Above All...and is Omnipotent Omnipresent. He is Beyond the the Human Intellect can even Dream or Imagine. Far more superior than what our Logic and Comprehension may be. I see The Smoke.... But I dont see the One with the Gun.... Meaning.... I see Trees, Mountains, Planets, Space, The Sun, the Moon, and Even NUMBERS!....= All signs of a Creator...(ie Smoke).... But I DO NOT see the One Holding the GUN. (i.e. I do not see the Creator who Created all of Creation)... which makes Perfect Sense, Since the Creator (Source) Would have to be Unseen...Hidden because HE is above "Light Complextion, mass, weight, color, Smell, taste, etc... (all attributes of creations). I see the Bread crumbs...I just dont see the one who left them...and perhaps I will never see the One...because Once you "See" the One...You realize...then...That THAT is NOT the One... because the ONE is above ALL Visual Limitations. All we can feel is the Spirit that was breathed inside of us. ie. we all have a special connection with the source. Maybe if we do what He says... we can get Closer to the Source. Also NOTE Allah's Attributes are "The Hidden One" "The Unseen". I think after an Atheist Thinks about that ...His head will just explode... lol I think the atheist will just give up giveup and say... "wow, I dont know it all" I think the Muslims will just give up giveupand say...."wow, I dont know it all either"... and Inshallah All of Mankind and Jinn will give up giveup and realize they they are the Servant NOT the master. Allah Humbles us. Allah knows All. and is Superior. Know your place... hail angel peace
  • Fornication from the roots?

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    82 Views
    N
    hmm, then when does 'marriage' begin? how does one define 'marriage'? I'm not sure. I think of MMA to mean someone who you are in a relationship with and are commited to and marriage as the relationship which you have chosen to be the one you want to be in for the rest of your life. Thus a lifelong commitment.
  • Need your help

    23
    0 Votes
    23 Posts
    516 Views
    W
    Peace, I think that's just part of growing up, discovering who you are. The thing is you have to be positive, be busy, be "useful", be productive, be creative. And all the while not forgetting the god, and being grateful to him. And once in a while you just have to stand still, and reflect upon life and meditate. But it's counterproductive to be thinking bad/negative thoughts, or even thinking over everything you did and whether you did the right thing or did it the right way or what you are about to do etc. You just have to get your attitude right and have good intentions. Peace.
  • more damage is done than good

    30
    0 Votes
    30 Posts
    490 Views
    B
    I am not sure there was an Injeel that came to Jesus. There is no evidence of that whatsoever. 544 545 546 547 548 544 We have sent down the Torah, in it is a guidance and a light; the prophets who have submitted judged with it for those who are Jewish, and the Devotees, and the Priests, for what they were entrusted of the Book of God, and they were witness over. So do not be concerned with the people but be concerned with Me; and do not purchase with My revelations a cheap price. And whoever does not judge with what God has sent down, then these are the rejecters. 545 And We have decreed for them in it that a life for a life, and an eye for an eye, and a nose for a nose, and an ear for an ear, and a tooth for a tooth, and wounds to be similar; and whoever remits anything of it, then it will cancel sins for him. And whoever does not judge with what God has sent down, then these are the wicked. 546 And We sent in their footsteps Jesus, son of Mary, authenticating what was present with him of the Torah. And We gave him the Gospel, in it is a guidance and a light, and authenticating what was present with him of the Torah, and a guidance and a lesson for the righteous. 547 And let the people of the Gospel judge with what God has sent down in it. And whoever does not judge with what God has sent down, then these are the wicked. And if they had upheld the Torah and the Gospel, and what was sent down to them from their Lord, they would have been rewarded from above them and from beneath their feet. From among them is a pious nation, but most of them only do evil. 566 Say O people of the Book, you are not upon anything until you uphold the Torah and the Gospel and what was sent down to you from your Lord. And for many of them, what was sent down to you from your Lord will only increase them in transgression and rejection. So do not feel sorry for the rejectors 568
  • My problem

    14
    0 Votes
    14 Posts
    130 Views
    S
    Salam Thanks for the advice guys, it really helped. I cant get myself to do certain things like listen to music though. Its like a part of me. Salam
  • Jumma Prayer

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    75 Views
    B
    Quran Aloners.... I like "Quran-Togethers' "Better! ;D D Yes we "Muslims" and Try to Practice the Real Sunnah the best we can. If you think about it we are basically trying to be "Sunnah"...(Quran alone is Sunnah)lol I read all of the Other Friday Jummah Topics and have this as my Conclusion... Eh-Hem....cough I am Sick of being help up by this dogmatic and Paradoxical State. Many have said... "Oh you cant do ---Blank----- because this one group of pagans along time ago did it for pagan reasons" ..."Therefore you can no longer do it. since its pagan in origin" I wont subscribe to this belief because I am Sure Pagans did just about everything, and that does not mean anything to me. Pagans Worshiped their false God's on Sunday, Friday, and Starurady and actually on EVERYDAY... Sunday was used to worship the sun. Friday was used to worship a Pagan god... But this really doesnt mean anything to me since I Neither Worship a pagan god on Friday, nor do I on Sunday. So therefore, Since I worship "Allah" the Omnipotent, I can do son on Friday, or on Sunday, or Any/Everyday.! ;D D Also, I personally Choose to do the Traditional Friday Jummah because I feel it is necessary in my Area since Friday is the Last "official Working day". It is Traditionally the Most Convenient day, and its contents coincide with the Quran. Tradtional Friday Jummah by a Muslim 0)Prayer Call to Allah, saying Allah Alone...is the Greatest, Come to Salah. Praying to Allah is so awesome. Pray to Allah, 2)Listen to an insightful kutbah about reflecting on submission and Gloriying Allah. 3)Sit with My Muslim Bro's and Sis's and enjoy their close company 4)Salat Jummah Pray to Allah 5)Put some Zakat money in the Jar (or physically do it myself outside) Go back to my Work daily business If Jummah Prayer on Friday is like this.... I dont see how it is at all "Wrong". If one wishes to not participate in this Jummah and Choose another day to do it, or do it in his own home....fine that his own decision. For me though, Juammah on Friday is Internationally known and si well established. so for convenient and traditional reasons, ill stick to Friday. (Still bearing in mind that Allah's word is #1(quran), and it is Allah who is giving me this opportunity to do this.) Note* I dont think ALL TRADITIONS are Haram and should be avoided. Only Traditions that don't co-inside with the Quran ;D Example. It is Traditional to Give a "Cheers" to your Friends and Family when Eating/Drinking. is this Practice Haram? I dont think so, it co-insides, because you are being Respectful to your Fellow Brethren, and are doing it with good intentions. Example, If I was Christian, I would Meet togeather with other christians for the Kutbah on Sunday. sun Not because of the SUN, and SUN worship..... But because it is internationally Known to be Sunday for Christians. Worshiping the God of Christ on Sunday. ie. Worship Allah on Sunday. (nothing to do with the Sun, since Allah created it!) ;D And that's my Conclusion! Very good input. For me the khutbah(sermon) is a problem more than the actual prayers. I like you believe its Ok especially if you have friends and relatives and so on who go to Jumua' or you live in a country where Jumi'a is a good place to meet people. I just wished the khutbah was Quranic. Friday prayers has a very good advantage in the sense it helps those who never pray or read the Quran an opportunity to do so at least once a week. But the khutbah needs to change. I think that the translation should not be based on ideological intepretations. We don't question sabt(saturday) regarding the sabbath in the Quran so why just Jumua'? More research needs to be done on this. But to be honest other than friday and saturday the rest of the Arabic week is numbers. So there is some mystery about this. The Ummayds could have just invented a week day like friday to copy the Christians or Jews.
  • Climategate!

    34
    0 Votes
    34 Posts
    639 Views
    T
    Oh, just that this has taken on the looks of a mysterious and sordid affair. Money, manipulative scientists, more money, unidentified hacker, more money, a lucky break at an opportune time, more money, a concerted effort that seems set on not allowing quick dissemination of "climategate," more money, believers, more money, deniers, more money, the Copenhagen conference, more money. The only certainty would seem to be a catastrophe somewhere and in some form. Let's enjoy in the meanwhile.
  • What do you think regarding the title of my upcoming book?

    27
    0 Votes
    27 Posts
    383 Views
    B
    What do you think regarding the title of my upcoming book? God willing, I am going to publish my debates with Robert Spencer, Ali Sina, Bill Warner, and other enemies of islam, peace and truth. These people have been promoting wars, torture, and genocide against Muslims... Several days ago, I listened to Robert Spencer; he was interviewed by fascist Michael Savage, the hate-monger radio talk show host. Spencer has a new book against the Quran. The title was something like this Idiot's Complete Guide to the Quran. So, I would like to consult you regarding the title of my book, which will inshallah be published within two months via Brainbow Press. Here are some of the candidates... I would like readers to see the book at Amazon.com when they type the names of these guys. Please come with your own suggestion if you have any Zionazis! Exposing Robert Spencer, Ali Sina, Bill Warner, David Horowitz and other Warmongers Zionazi Crusaders Exposing Robert Spencer, Ali Sina, Bill Warner, David Horowitz and other Warmongers Zionazi Christofascists Exposing Robert Spencer, Ali Sina, Bill Warner, David Horowitz and other Warmongers Three Scoundrels Exposing Robert Spencer, Ali Sina, Bill Warner, and other Warmongers Complete Intelligent Guide for Idiots Robert Spencer, Ali Sina, Bill Warner and David Horowitz .... Peace, Edip Why not write a book about your debates with other Quranist?
  • All religions are okay?

    109
    0 Votes
    109 Posts
    3k Views
    J
    have come to ruku`and sujud, haven't we &nbsp salamun alaykum san, simple & all, if we may say, 'iman' is 'to believe', 'ruku'' is 'to acknowledge', and 'sujud' is 'to give respect'. while 'asm'' is 'status'. in our current comprehension that is, and the salient issues contained in al-AAalaq (http//free-minds.org/quran/PM/96) are (selected few among the many) a. your 'rabb' is the one who created man b. He created man to depend on Him c. He taught what man does not know d. but man is too much, in that he regard himself to be able to know by himself e. indeed to your 'rabb' is the reference (read c) etc. but what is 'rabb'? in simple english, 'rabb' implies 'the one in control' or perhaps the ideas regarding 'rabb' can be gathered around the following words; owner-master-lord. stage 1 the knowledge or information regarding the 'rabb', man and knowledge. stage 2 one believes (iman) or disbelieve (la yu'min) stage 3 when one believes (iman), one should acknowledge or accept the facts (ruku&#039 the 'rabb' - to acknowledge It's status & roles in one's life. otherwise one will dismiss or deny the information regarding the 'rabb' - thus such a one becomes a 'mukazzib'. stage 4 only one who has acknowledged the status of one's 'rabb' will give the respect (sujud). iman, ruku' & sujud are pregnant words indeed. some examples a. the rabb or lord is the one that should be the only one in control of one's being (mind, feel & deeds), but what is the one in control of you now? is it your mind? is it your emotion? or is it another person? what did the qur'an say about the creations of the mind? also of the feel? and of course of other people? we can learn the details of these in the qur'an, couldn't we? b. when one acknowledges the fact that one in control of one's being should only be the rabb, it is only proper that one should know much more about one's rabb. only in later surah could we come across the very idea about God or 'Allah'. what does this fact say about God? and there are people who often unknowingly appointed multiple gods, sometimes together with God - thus a mushrik one became. c. to have other 'rabb' is to appoint equals or rivals for God - it is to be disrespectful to God. to be prejudiced is also to be disrespectful to God. to wrong one's understanding is to be disrespectful to God too. and the list regarding man's disrespectful attitudes can be very lengthy, but suffice to say that some believers have so often blatantly been disrespectful to God. and most do not realize about their disrespect to God. thus the frequent call is 'aqeemoo al-salat wa-atoo alzakat' or 'correct your relationships with purified hearts', especially the relationship with God. one who has corrected one's relationship with God will slowly but surely be guided to enjoy excellent relationships with other people, and whatever is there in the skies and the earth and in between them both. God's promise is 'wala hawfun AAalayhim, wala hum yahzanoon.' but this is merely our current comprehension. if one wants to know the truth, one could easily ask God about it, for God is closer than what the fools have usually thought. and may God guide us all on the correct path. insha-Allah. peace! mohammed noh
  • Free Minds Quran Translation?

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    28 Views
    J
    Great! Got a couple ordered. Thanks Wakas.
  • Was Nelson Mandella a prophet like Abraham?

    9
    0 Votes
    9 Posts
    18 Views
    U
    Every Prophet and Every Political Leader I History of Man had to go against Evil Authorities in one form or another. When You mean Like, You are saying Similar Traits? Correct. Not Literally "A Prophet". I think the Prophets are Examples of Kahlifas that are here for us. Therefore, ANYTIME we are given a Trial or Tribulation in our life, We in some form or Fashion, Resemble or at least Carry a Similar Trait that the Prophets had when they were here. For example, If you were a Whistle Blower Who Used to Work for a Corrupted Government, But then repented and Now made it your Mission to expose the Inner Truths and Free the People.... Id say you are "Like" Moses. But Nelson Mandella? I dont know... You'd have to Really Explain and Clarify How he shares a Commonality with Ibrahim. I see Ibrahim (pbuh) as a Highly Respectful God-Fearing Wise Father. One Who Humbly Looks for God, and Thinks Very Logically and Stands Firm. One who doesn't Get Angry very Easily, but will go to war when needed. A Father archetype. Does Nelson Mandella Fit this Role? Perhaps your Question or Poll should Read... What Prophet do you think Nelson Mandella shares the most Common Traits with? ) I think i agree with you guys, but my quistion should have been who was the righteous man for the S.Africans or something- as Abraham has a meaning and what would the S.Africans say? was the righteous man for them in history. Of course in the case of the jews the most righteous man was the one who argued with the then pharoah on their behalf, and i wonder who was the most righteous man for pakistan e.t.c All men who work for the cause of righteousness are i think very close to the All-mighty,No? peace Although as you said Abraham might be the very person Nelson himself followed,Yep.
  • Mythology

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    10 Views
    S
    ) Definitely excitement is part of it, and toughness too. Peace, R. nothing more exciting and challenging, then! ) Thanks for the link. Peace
  • Concordance

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    35 Views
    M
    Hi everybody. First off I'd like to introduce myself as I'm just registered. I'm Joseph (male) mid 30's and live in London, England though I'm not English. I'm looking for suggestions on good concordances. In English or Arabic, Transliterated etc. I don't mind. Thanks in advance and I look forward as always to reading your posts. Joseph. welcome to the forum
  • My problems with Free-Minds (very long post, please read)

    80
    0 Votes
    80 Posts
    2k Views
    N
    But they're not consistent. I already stated that they're not consistent in the way how Salaat should be performed, but they're consistent in that Salaat is worship/ritual prayer. All of them, from the most "authentic" ones to the "weak" and "fabricated." I think that's what I've been saying all along? It's not matter how this worship is performed as long as it doesn't violate the Qur'an (a.k.a setting up partners, etc.). It is a bond where we worship God and remember Him at specific times throughout the day. Some people don't see this by reading the Qur'an, but I do. Now if you're saying that Salaat is something else like "doing good deeds" or some other theory, then no, I would have to disagree there. Yes we can do it differently, I do it differently and I gave my reasons why. But we can't just do anything we want and slap the name "Salaat" on it. Some people have been saying that "doing good deeds" is Salaat, or simply "remembering God" without doing anything physically at all it "Salaat." I completely agree. I have said that many times. Doing it the way the hadeeth describe it (or the ways the hadeeth describe it) violates the Qur'an, in my opinion. I already gave my reasons why in a previous post. Read up on what I said regarding Tashhahud etc. And God knows best. Sorry for the late reply. I keep forgetting to check the threads i have written in. Let me tell you where i am with this. If you want to use hadith to influence the way you uphold salat, then i think it is ok so long as you don't think that they are necessary to use. A hadith is like other books it will have bad in it and good or possibly neither or just one of the two. It is not divine. I disagree with you on the physical aspect of it. I am also open to the possibility that salat can mean good deeds as others have posted but i also think that it also means the salat in which we are discussing. Not sure on the times (fajr, esha) as it would not make sense for certain times to be special but still it seems pretty clear in the Q that those are the times. So i will try and stick to those times. I have felt a bit better when upholding at those times. But that could just be my bias or unconcious mind which thinks of the Quran's timing.
  • THE QURAN CONFIRMS: TODAY'S BIBLE IS UNCHANGED

    54
    0 Votes
    54 Posts
    1k Views
    J
    Why is taurat/injeel not mentioned in 1746? Why quran alone? Does this leave room for another book? Can people readily reject what you call the torah and/or the bible, since this verse mentions QURAN ALONE? Find me a verse, just one verse, that that says at-tauraat was given to Moosa. It is indeed Isa (not moosa) who teaches (and was taught) both at-tauraat AND al-injeel (348, 5110), along with al-kitab and alhikmah. Moosa was given kitabun-moosa (1117, 4612). He, along with his brother, were given 'al-furqan' (254. We are also told to believe in what was sent down to Ibrahim, Ismail, Ishaaq, Yaaqoob, and Al-asbat (384). Where are these books ? Btw, bani israel doesn't refer to jews. Bani israil are descendants of Noah (173). Don't forget in chapter 71 he prays for the annihilation of all kafireen on earth. -Ibrahim sprang from Noah's group(3783). And Ibrahim was not (usually translated as jewish and christian) 2140. Peace
  • Kapparot

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    30 Views
    C
    Makes me think of voodoo. Anybody ever see that documentary Divine Horsemen? Weird, but interesting.
  • Eid Festival ,Islamic or unislamic ?

    16
    0 Votes
    16 Posts
    178 Views
    A
    http//en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_sacrifice