Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.2k Topics 133.0k Posts
  • Polygamy and "Right hand Possess" in the Koran- new outlook

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    14 Views
    WakasW
    I assumed the limit came from AQ from 43, as I quoted above. If the article you refer to is any decent, I assume it reviews 43 and refutes the understanding of 4 being a limit. If it does not mention 43 then sounds pretty poor to me.
  • Roots of bible's pagan full moon rituals in ancient india?

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    36 Views
    T
    Autumn Equinox Seventh Month Tishri (Hebrew) Tashritum (Babylonian) (late September-early October) (end dry season) New Moon - New Half-Year - in the magical seventh month On this New Year's Day, eat something sweet (honey) first and avoid sour foods, to magically bring sweetness in coming year. Autumnal Equinox September 19, 20, 21, 22 Intercalary Purification Fast Day - 10th day after New Moon At this time people at home light no fires and perform acts of expiation and purification. In ancient times there was a Bull sacrifice in temple; a Goat sacrifice in temple, and a Scape-goat was sent to Azazel into wilderness to transfer any evil from humans to animal. In Modern Europe Kiparot on day before before Yom Kippur (= Day of Awe), Orthodox Jewish men are lightly flogged at their synagogue, a hold-over from the actions of mourning or ecstacy performed by celebrants in ancient days. At home, to purify and chase away evil, swing a white rooster around one's head, then sacrifice it, or drive it away, or throw into running water, or give the bird to the poor to eat. FULL MOON - Feast of Harvest In-Gathering - Week Long Festival This week long festival marks the end of the grape harvest and the final Harvest Home. The Canaanites ate, drank, and reveled, marking the end of agricultural year and the beginning of the rainy season. Dance processions wound their way through the fields under the full moon's light almost until dawn. Celebrants would carry palm leaves, and olive, myrtle and willow branches bound together and hanging with fruit. Major animal sacrifices were performed at the temple, but the poor could offer a jar of flour or oil or a jug of wine instead. During the festival, prayers and magic are made for rain. Normally, after the burning of the daily sacrifice, libations of wine are poured on the altar. During Sukkot, a special libation of water is also poured. A priest with a golden ewer goes down from mount of the temple to a special sacred spring to draw water. He returns to temple through what is called the Water Gate, where other priests blow silver trumpets. Another group of priests gather long willow branches which are placed alongside the altar with their tips curving inward. The water priest pours the holy water over the altar in a magical practice to bring rain, after which libation all the priests march around altar carrying the willow withes in a magic circle. This activity is watched by men carrying bundles of leaves from the palm tree, sacred to the Athirat. At night, men dance in temple whirling torches until cock crow. At end, the priests circumabulate the altar seven times, then beat the earth with willow branches, a magical practice to make the earth fertile. Hmm. Music, dancing, eating, drinking, making magic, making merry. And more. What is it with these pagan loonies? It must be the fool moon. al'hamd li Allaah Rabb al'aalameen
  • Ahl Quran website has now been banned where I am from

    10
    0 Votes
    10 Posts
    21 Views
    WakasW
    Quran Alone people i.e. 19ers It is evident from the fact that they reject all capital punishments Clearly you have no idea what you are talking about. http//www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&q=define%3A+evidence&btnG=Google+Search&meta=&aq=f&oq=
  • Which book cover is better?

    14
    0 Votes
    14 Posts
    45 Views
    T
    Peace, To add to all the comments, the second one is actually a male symbol and thus can be misunderstood as biased towards males. I would go with the third choice too with the change in colors.
  • Satan is a temporary God

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    85 Views
    V
    La ilahe illa Allah! There is no god (be temporary or otherwise) only the god. Khalifa does not mean ilah (god) or Allah (God or the god). Khalifa means, afterwards, follower... Humans were created after a violent species on earth. Using Rashad's obvious translation error and even going beyond his intended meaning, is theologically a very risky path. I do believe that Satan is smirking through this translation to those who would call him god! (Knowingly or unknowingly you used the word God (with capital letter meaning "the god" or al-ilah, that is Allah). Furthermore, verse 4345 is sufficient to refute the title of your post. Peace, Edip Dear Mr.Edip, I share your views about this post but I'm not yet sure about the correctness of your translation of the word Khalifa as a follower. It is generally translated as a viceroy. I'm really wondering how could you still believe in code 19 and accept Rashad Khalifa as a messenger of God when he went astray to the extent that he advocated Satan as a temporary god and misguided ignorant people. Peace, K.Vivekanandan
  • The quraan & the mishnah

    14
    0 Votes
    14 Posts
    132 Views
    T
    bigmo-Those who have not inherited Divine scriptures. That is my opinion, too -- that ummiyyeen had not previously received a divine book, & this is confirmed by the quraan. -The Koran says that those who said to Muhamamd this is what was sent to Moses had no knowledge of the scriptures. I think its talking about the inventors of the Talmud. From 7157 & 622, v know that the ummiyyeen is not interchangeable with pagan. From 375, it is clear that the people of the book were not ummiyyeen. 278 talks about the ummiyyeen among the jews & christians who only had fancies & no knowledge about the book. 4123 also talks about similar vain fancies. Judaism & christianity had infiltrated the deserts of arabia long before the revelation of the quraan. It is my understanding that the ummiyyeen of 278 are these converts to judaism & christianity who were not recipients of any divine scripture, & not short of fancy & conjecture. ma'a salaam. God bless all. al'hamd li Allaah Rabb al'aalameen
  • Shahr (new moon)

    8
    0 Votes
    8 Posts
    94 Views
    WakasW
    peace, The specific use of "full moon" is not mentioned in PRL for BDR. It does list "become full/grown/round" however. The listing has now been changed to "become full/grown/round/large (e.g. full moon)". Again, as stated in the PRL homepage it is a work in progress.
  • New Afghan Law- Women must let husband have sex every 4 days

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    42 Views
    J
    Shalom , Peace , Asalaam alaikoum All I don't accept satan brickwall brickwall brickwall brickwall for to make a law between me and my wife . laugh laugh laugh , poor women living in a big prison ,, praying God for this country maybe they'll get wisdom from others countries who're on the best way for the development . Shalom Abd-Allah Mecherbet
  • reformist quran translation & its translators

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    55 Views
    T
    Thanks for the dope. ma'a salaam. God bless all. al'hamd li Allaah Rabb al'aalameen
  • heaven, hell - environment and how to get there?

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    70 Views
    F
    Thanks darcus... it's really nice to hear your thought. We know kung fu now... laugh (remembering Neo tells Morpheus that he knows kung fu <so cool!&gt I don't think this would meet free-mind standards for an article due to lack of Quranic reference... but it's enough at least for me to answer the OP question... yes I just know the fundamental of this process, based from others collective experiences. But to actually know what is there, we have to be there and personally verify it for ourselves. The problem is you have to be dead to experience it. Lol. There are other ways like doing Out of body, NDE, or just feel the feeling of it. Try to think about heaven in any sacred places that you like. For Muslim i believe Mecca and mosque is the best place. The vibration of heaven is very high there. Billions of Muslims agreed that Mecca is a sacred place. Imagine the energy that it have. In that place just close your eyes and allow the feeling to come. The purer the intent, the easier it is to perceive the signal. It is indeed a lovely and memorable feeling. It's so indescribable, only tears will come out. ) Thanks again for reading. handshake Edit It doesn't have to be at any sacred place tho. But it does help. Sometimes a song, a movie, words, thoughts about God's creation or even some unexpected event can trigger this connection with the signal. When it comes, just allow it. And you know it's true. Enjoy. yay
  • Internet Pornography Statistics

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    100 Views
    R
    i wouldn't be the least bit surprised if this is true. sex has become a connection-less act, just to get off. there is nothing wrong with sex within a solid committed relationship. look at the youth, they have become so vulgar...no more playing with cars and barbie. reality tv is filthy. the family will soon become a thing of the past. porn is mentally poisoning us, like a mental illness or something.
  • Fear god?

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    70 Views
    R
    I mean why do we need to fear someone we love, and allah who loves us back. Can someone explain what they mean by fear allah the all forgiving? Peace. how can god love us? to say god loves us (or any other emotion)...wouldn't that be saying we have some type of control and affect over god's "emotions"? god just is. i see these as just terms for human beings who feel emotion.
  • Who is that educated messenger in 44:14?

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    62 Views
    B
    This is my interpretation. Whats yours? Peace My understanding It is a predetermined command from us that we send messengers. In future more than one Therefore, watch for the day when the sky brings a profound smoke. It will envelope the people; this is a painful retribution. I have republished the following report in my site in Jan4th 1999. Images link are broken please go to here. And read this article NANOTECHNOLOGY AND THE NEXT 50 YEARS R. E. Smalley Presentation University of Dallas - Board of Councilors December 7, 1995 http//web.archive.org/web/20010604093405/http//cnst.rice.edu/images/069.jpg The people at 2050 say "Our Lord, relieve this retribution for us; we are believers." And Go knows future and responding like this 4413] Now that it is too late, they remember! An enlightening messenger had come to them. But they turned away from him, saying, "Well educated, but crazy!" Peace
  • Open Burhan

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    31 Views
    B
    There is no offline version, but you can run it locally. You need some technical knowlege of databases and php to get it working. The version of openburhan that you see at openburhan.com is not hosted by me. The project was opensource and a few people have hosted their versions of openburhan. I still own the domain "openburhan.com" and simply pointed it to a version that seemed like was making good progress. Textinmotion.org is an another version, has a much cleaner look like the orginal used to be, plus you can add your input to it. I am working on a brand new ob - available hopefully next year. So if have any feature requests now is the time to PM them to me. One feature which I will NOT include is "offline" - simply because it is not the way forward (look at google docs) and significantly limits the scope of what a web application can do. Inshallah when it goes live, it will be only the Quran application that you will ever use. Thats the aim anyway.
  • 0 Votes
    54 Posts
    958 Views
    T
    smmirza-I fail to understand how you are so sure that Kaaba is God's house and is sacred. Do you have any verses in the Quran that you could share? The kaaba is the bayt as per the quraan (597) From an earlier dialogue between us -Which implies that you believe that the Kaaba is something holy/special/venerated. The kaaba is special/blessed as per the quraan (396) Do u have an alternate translation? Also, from the quraan the bayt can be traced to abraham & ishmael (2127). & v know that the ""standing" of ishmael & muhammad has been rejected by the jews & christians; then, the aversion of the rejectors (397) is along expected lines. ma'a salaam. God bless all. al'hamd li Allaah Rabb al'aalameen
  • image file of 'alhamdulillah' in arabic script

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    111 Views
    N
    awesome, thank you
  • We Koranist must save the Muslim youths in Western nations

    26
    0 Votes
    26 Posts
    418 Views
    B
    Salafism is stronger than ever. I cant wait for the emergence of alternative energy so Saudi Arabia will be back to its desert way fighting over a well and not having enough money to build 'evil' mosques throughout the world. And do you think if it wasn't for the rise of fudamentalism we would have a market? In fact many of us would not be here if it wasn't for Salafism and how it made us feel that something ain't right here. So the more it spreads the more salafi burn outs and the more liberals feeling the need to look for alternative explanations. In fact the printing press and the distribution of the hadith material and its availability with people like Ayaan Ali, Wafa Sultan and Robert Spencer is helping Koranism rise. But I think what Sarat said about how the Islamic identity and its intertwining with people's culture is a hard stumbling block is very important for us to consider. It means forget about old people living in rural community who see Islam like its a tribal custom and a national lifestyle. But I enjoyed some of her observation. I can see how each one of us have a different experience depending on the kinds of people we interact with. I am a net guy, I believe the more information is spread around in the net the more it will trickle down to society. But there is one thing I wnat to share. In an interview on TV, former Sudanese de facto leader and Islamist ideologue but now turned reformist, Hassan Al Turabi, said that he found that going directly to the masses with small literature requires a lot of work as people rarely read and are not too easy to change. He said that as a criticism about his Islamist movement. He said that a better way was to right detailed books with lots of information and arguments and insights that intellectuals read and then these intellectuals trickle it down to society. This is something I have been thinking of. Its lucky that most intellectuals are big time internet users. And I think thats how the debate about the Israel Lobby in America burst open, it was through the net as Walt and Mearsheimer also observed. The traditional forced generally are controlling the traditional media outlets such as mosques and recently newspapers and libraries and TV and radio. But I wonder why Turabi said that. Some people say never trust what he says. But I think it was an important observation as he was active from the 50s but like many Islamist he targeted students and used catchy slogans but he seems to think it ruined the Islamist agenda. Some say he ruined it with his hypocrysy and greed.
  • quick question ; What is the right way?

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    183 Views
    B
    In the quran is says that a person should obey their parents right? What if you want to do something that you know isn't wrong in islam and with the best intention even if it's againt you parents permisson. Is this wrong? PEACE. ) Peace
  • Daawa.

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    17 Views
    D
    Peace The dawat-e-islam group is what you're thinking of there. They have 'kafla's in different towns inviting people to be better barelwis. Best form of dawa in my opinion is that of 'by example'. Rather than approaching people, let them approach you because of what they see you doing or how you do things. If you do voluntary work in your local community for example, sweep up the glass in the road on the way to the mosque, those sort of things will get you recognised and people will want to talk to you, at that stage you gently ease your view of thinking into what they're asking. My family are barelwis and slowly, over the last few years they are beginning to see the holes in their beliefs and the shirk is not so rampant. It is still there, but gently. Better that they make the decision themselves than you be a blunt instrument. This is my method, may or may not work for you.
  • ironsky (kurt)

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    57 Views
    N
    Peace nimnimak kurt used to be a active member of this forum ,a short while ago .one of his last posts was of him getting fired from work for telling the truth . I was wounderring if any body had heard from him lately and if he was alright. Peace Salim Peace Salim thank you for letting me know. i hope he is fine. i sort of become active and unactive on this forum as well. it's down to how busy i am and how well i remember to come on. maybe his busy finding another job. Peace Nyma