Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.2k Topics 133.1k Posts
  • Extraquranic revelation?

    17
    0 Votes
    17 Posts
    175 Views
    S
    The issue resolved, and understood. It is a proven fact that Mohammad(pbuh) did recieve extra quranic guidance, weather rest of the humainty needs it , or not ? that was decided by the author of Quran, what he thought was necessary, he included it in the Book. opf! i was too dumb to extract any thing out of your post , but burhan's one line made me understand, but thanks handshake for giving it a try. The extra quranic revelation was meant only for the prophet, it's between him and God. You weren't the ones marrying Zainab, or disclosing a secret to the prophets' wives or burying the prophets uncle. Burhan! thanks, by the way No body is for taking in bukhari and co, peace siki
  • Declare yourself.

    65
    0 Votes
    65 Posts
    2k Views
    G
    Peace All, Thanx for your responses. I am no longer participating in this thread since it's gone hopelessly fftopic long ago.
  • Is it wrong to participate in the christmas holiday?

    32
    0 Votes
    32 Posts
    528 Views
    D
    Salaam dotty, Allah knows secrets of our hearts and is most merciful. I hope you make most of holiday season with your six year old daughter. These are wonderful moments and do take picture of her when she is enjoying bit of pampering on this occasion. Your little flexibility today will pay back later insha?Allah and soon she will be big enough to understand meaning of consumerism and real Santa. Lots of love to your little one Best regards farida Thank you farida!
  • Is Damon Banned?

    18
    0 Votes
    18 Posts
    203 Views
    M
    handshake Peace be on you... peace
  • You Hear Voices in your Head, heres why

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    52 Views
    U
    So seek refuge recite Anasi 114 farida And can you explain what good parroting that surah will do except drown out the voice if you do it loud enough? No offense intended. Nothing to care. This is actually reasonably old technology using ultrasound to direct everything and it was featured on news years ago. How would you intimidate people using voting machines with that? Why wouldn't you just ignore their choice, if you had access to the machine, and count your chosen candidate instead of theirs? Ockham's razor )
  • Bermuda Triangle?

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    16 Views
    U
    Load of exaggerated rubbish, that's what.
  • Which place should we like to visit - instead of Mecca?

    9
    0 Votes
    9 Posts
    25 Views
    D
    . Definitely not makkah but Bukkah; where is it? Until Allah is pleased with me and decides to allow me there, He wont reveal its whereabouts!
  • **What Dreams May Come**

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    34 Views
    M
    Glad you brought this movie up. I haven't seen it in a long time. Maybe a good movie to revisit. The after life concept was very much like the concepts I've heard certain mystics believe in, even the reincarnation part too. I'm not sure if I subscribe to the idea mainly because it was so material , but definitly intersting for sure! peace
  • My Interview at FrontaPageMagazine.com

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    69 Views
    M
    Salam Edip.. it was nice to read about your past. Had no idea! Good for you.. and congrats.... peace. peace
  • 0 Votes
    3 Posts
    20 Views
    WakasW
    Quran a Reformist Translation You can download the entire thing here http//groups.google.com/group/19org/files Direct link (right click and save target as) http//19org.googlegroups.com/web/Quran%3A%20a%20Reformist%20Translation%200979671507.pdf
  • Problems with the Reformist Translation

    58
    0 Votes
    58 Posts
    1k Views
    WakasW
    Quran a Reformist Translation You can download the entire thing here http//groups.google.com/group/19org/files Direct link (right click and save target as) http//19org.googlegroups.com/web/Quran%3A%20a%20Reformist%20Translation%200979671507.pdf
  • what's going on?

    12
    0 Votes
    12 Posts
    120 Views
    P
    I'm wondering about the characters added to the letters. If these are in any way, shape or form different. Some different meanings arise. E.g. Malek VS Malak
  • doing good and helping others

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    20 Views
    J
    does that include giving food to people who are richer then us? Absolutely not, why would you do that? The whole point in giving is giving to the needy.
  • 0 Votes
    38 Posts
    878 Views
    A
    Salaam Arnold Yasin, Salaam amuslim, As for the concept of worship, that is another discussion, so we leave that for the future. No, paying zakat is not enough, it is the whole package that makes Islam work as a system for Mankind. Christians, Jews and so on pay tax now also, not for the benefit of Mankind, but just because the government wants it, they follow the laws not to get in trouble, not because they support them directly. They just want to profess their beliefs, nothing more. They do good to individuals, but are not busy with creating a fair wellfare system and help mankind. The Western wellfare were created under secular rule, not under Christian rule... This is the difference with a Muslim, that person wants to follow the Laws because he knows it is best for Mankind, he wants to pay zakat as he knows it will help others and the whole nation and so on. The intention is different, and God judges us on intention. I agree with the intention. However, what I don't understand from your point, is that you are saying that Christians and Jews pay taxes because its the government telling them to do so. What exactly stops Christians, Jews, or any person, to give to charities to benefit humankind, monthly, because they want to? The way I am understanding from your posts is that only true Muslims give for the benefit of mankind and that Christians, Jews, etc. give for personal salvation, required to do so, etc. and not for the benefit of humanity. I can see if you were to generalize it, but from the way I see it you are stating that all of them do it for those reasons. No offense, but where is the proof to make such a statement that all of them do it for those reasons? No they have 2 completely goals and create 2 completely different situations Survival of the fittest Stalin killed many many people using the rule survival of the fittest. Many communist regimes also used this rule as an excuse to kill and oppress the people. Hitler killed any weak race based on this rule. They killed people as they believed that only the fittest would survive, even WW1 was fought partialy because of this doctrine. Racism used this doctrine as a rule to profess the idea of superiority of certain races above the other. To act for the benefit of your species Cure diseases, stop hunger, create equal social and economic situations, stop wars and crimes... Wow..What a difference indeed... Because Stalin said (?) or insinuated that it was "survival of the fittest", we base it off of that? Its like the Nazi symbol, when in actuality it comes from other beliefs, from Eastern to Native Americans. When one says "Survival of the fittest", I interpret it that only the fittest for that environment/situation survives. Isn't that the definition of "survival of the fittest"? Again, isnt this all semantics? Act at the benefit of the species. Couldn't we connect this to natural selection? In the wild, the animals will even kill their own if they are not fit to survive so it doesn't get introduced into the gene pool. Peace
  • Common Cause

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    64 Views
    S
    Salaam Samia Point taken, back to the issue I think it is important to do "ijmaa3 and come to an agreement at least on the subject of Ramadan and lunar or solar calendar. I find it very confusing with all these views at variance with another; there is no reasons why we can?t respect each others view and at the same time maybe take a poll. I would be interested to know what would you think is the best way to approach a consensus and become the Ummah we?re supposed to be. Best regards farida I would like to apologize for being a bit out of order. And thanks for understanding. I would recommend starting with a solid foundation (e.g. one god/people/message, good deeds), and gradually build on that. ) peace. Start from the beginning? Or maybe I did not get your point?
  • Legal procedure to become a Muslim in India

    17
    0 Votes
    17 Posts
    185 Views
    A
    Salam. Wanna become a Muslim? Peace4life quoted the right verses submit to God. That's it. Sunnis have asked me what does a person say when s/he wants to becaome a Muslim? My answer is always this it's the thing in your heart that counts, not just the words. I have been saying for years i'm an actor, writer, director and a producer. people took me as a writer only after i wrote a script. They will recognise me as actor when they see me in the local cinema in a psychological thriller opposite Jennifer Love Hewitt and Gary Oldman. God willing. I will be a director after i direct a movie and a producer after i invest a certain amount of money in a movie. See my point? After you read The Quran and execute its orders and practice it, then you will be a Muslim. Ask God to guide you. Rely on God, trust God, God knows you don't, i don't and sunnis follow desires. Peace.
  • Eurocentric?

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    206 Views
    H
    (maybe better put is I didn't understand what is meant by "False values are also universal.&quot For instance, greed, brutality, power as selfdivinization, "I take whatever I can and damned everything else". Some of these values can be summarized as "success".
  • In Honey there is Healing

    39
    0 Votes
    39 Posts
    555 Views
    Z
    Peace afridi, Thats the article I posted above. peace
  • shirk

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    12 Views
    A
    Peace nerspi, This is the only sin that God will not forgive after death. a few questions i have what exactly is shirk? ok it's worskiping anything other than the One God, but what is that? how do we know we're not unintentionaly doing that? i read if one spends too much time with something, like the thing one ocupies his/her mind with the most, then that's his god. but what is too much time? if a man spends a lot of time with his wife and kids, does that mean he's worshiping them? is there a limit on how much time we can spend with anything else? Spouses, children, material things, etc. are all blessings that allow us (or that we should) to focus our praise and thankfulness to Allah. These are all reminders, similar to reading Quran. They should evoke our praises, not take over our focus. If you spend too much time with things and forget Allah, then you have just set up a partner IMO. In everything that you do, you have to have taqwa. Free Minds Translation 3832 He then said "I have enjoyed materialism more than I enjoyed the remembrance of my Lord; now it has become totally dark!" 3833 "Send them back." He then rubbed their legs and necks. Peace
  • Free Download Quran

    15
    0 Votes
    15 Posts
    172 Views
    J
    Peace, Thanks for the links! I wonder does anyone here recite the Quran and record it. I remember a member here was doing such a project. insha_Allah he's still doing it. Ah, I got tired of hearing my own voice...