Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.2k Topics 133.2k Posts
  • i'm new here

    16
    0 Votes
    16 Posts
    34 Views
    U
    salam... i didnt read everything, just skimmed, can't be on long now. but i just wanted to say the part about the Prophet living his life for us, i didnt mean it like being our savior or ba3rifish shuu. i meant what he had to go through to spread Islam etc etc. nothing like dying for our sins or anything like that.. nothing like that. Not on the surface of it sister. Im not going to argument my stand on the Quran with you, because i know it is the same. The Quran is the infallible word of God, and it was delivered to us by Mohammad (Gbh), period. What makes me different from you is that im very sceptic about anything added to this mighty formula, in this case hadith, when i find som many similarities between them and other relegious scriptures that are proveable rooted in worship of the heavens. Have you ever wondered about the door on the wall in the direction of mecca, in quite a few mosques? I know what we are being told it is, but the whole concept of the sacred door. the heavens gate, the sundoor. Is a very old and pagan one. There are so many things i would love for you to take a look at sister, before you condemn this site a cult or anything like it. Things that has nothing to do with the Quran, but EVERYTHING to do with torah, bible, india, canaan and worship of the heavens. But theres a bonus though sis. This stuff is really fascinating once you get in to it, and as you say, God knows best. ) Peace Noah
  • Psilocybin Mushrooms

    27
    0 Votes
    27 Posts
    546 Views
    U
    Ive done all kinds of stuff when i was younger. Natural i mean. Datura, devil leaf, you name it, i ate it. All it it does is to completely distort the input you recieve from the world. Sometimes things get so distorted that you start to see things that arent there, silly wierd things. I spoke for hours to a 3 meter tall demon character than suddenly walked out of my wall. Ugly as hell, but kinda nice guy really, and this after eating datura....i mean seriously. its bad for you. Peace TnE
  • If there was a Country with Quranic system than how?

    44
    0 Votes
    44 Posts
    665 Views
    A
    Dear David, So-called democracies or rather countries where leaderships are elected through the votes of the people, are majority ruled. Therefore if a majority can not be won for a system following the Qur?an, there can be no nation following the Qur?anic laws. The other possibility is, of course, implementing the laws by force. Another Iran, Iraq, Saudi Arabia............................. Not very tempting? So, we are left with the possibility to use democracy to win a majority for the laws of the Qur?an within an existing country, or to find other ways and means. The laws don?t seem possible to implement unless it happens on a certain area of land, guarded by human drawn borders. The options then seem to be Win election in an existing country and implement laws and rules based on the Qur?an. Gather people of like minds across borders, implementing whatever laws and rules of the Qur?an possible, under the laws of the various countries. I leave out the option of forceful implementation as that is breaching the law of God. Have I overlooked any other option? I really hope so, because both these options have already been deemed very unlikely to be ?do-able?. Then, how? Best regds Ali Omar
  • Who witnessed the scorching full-moon/shahr ramadan?

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    135 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you, I think that speaks to the materialist influence many of us are under, we should be aware of EVERY full moon as it marks TIME. I witnessed it without even intending to D It just came across my vision.
  • Angels?who eat up roasted calf...........

    12
    0 Votes
    12 Posts
    25 Views
    U
    Salaams All, not everybody will agree with me and neither everybody agree with you- i think, I wouldn't accept anybody giving their daughters away to anybody even under such a situation but someone else might . Good for them. Salaams.
  • Free will or determinism ?

    26
    0 Votes
    26 Posts
    94 Views
    K
    Peace Anwar X committing the act and not God does not say that there is another God besides God. Simply because X has (or should I say, been given) the capacity to act right or wrong. I suggest that you reflect even "deeper", better yet, reflect holistically. Think on this (as will I), to do the most 'minimal' of tasks requires God, the life force flowing through all that is. You do not commit any act, as 'You' is only a narrow perspective on things, in reality God is all there is and all thought that we draw from is God. When we judge an action we limit the thoughts that our mind will embrace, is thought not God? Then embrace all thought to become unlimited in our very being, do not judge thought if you wish to open your mind. If God is actually committing the act of rape and not X, then this God has to be unjust, no matter how much wisdom you throw in. Look at anything you see and tell me is there more or less God in any of what you see. If there is more God in any act or space then what is the rest if not God. This is why I ask the question Is there a God besides God? Tell me how is rape wrong and how is rape right? For right to exist so must wrong, if God is right then what besides God is wrong? According to your wise thinking, all those who commit attrocities/crimes should go scott free and shouldn't be held accountable for their crimes and let the innocent suffer! What ever one experiences is because they have chosen to experience. We are here right now because we chose to be here, one who fears rape will inevatibly draw this onto their self, when one confronts their fears peace is the natural outcome. On earth we experience our thoughts manifested, whatever we experience was a thought we harboured. The innocent should be happy instead of suffering because it is God who is suffering and not them. ! The innocent will be innocent if thats what they hold their self to be as we become what we think. And please tell me who is not happy on this plane here, for all are expressing their self; wether they desire to express sorrow, joy, anger, love, hate or laughter is thier choice. If we did not express our selves we would die. peace,
  • Give "idolfree1" moderator status - he deserves it

    18
    0 Votes
    18 Posts
    203 Views
    M
    Salaamun Alaik Bro. Kyle, Congratulations on your new posting for new position. ) May Allah keep you kool even on this position ) But still All praises be to Allah. Best regards, MMKhan
  • Are we all One?

    45
    0 Votes
    45 Posts
    1k Views
    U
    Peace be upon you Peace, Wow thanks for your responses. I just finished reading the online book, and it was really helpful, I think I'm going to re-read it and try to grasp everything that it talks about. I was amazed at how it answered the questions that I was asking myself before. I think once we open our mind up to exploring something, the answers seem to find us. I'm going to place Metu Neter on hold at my university library. I am glad you enjoyed it as I thought you would, and yes, it takes a few readings for it to really verify itself. Metu Neter, in my opinion, is much deeper. It speaks about the same people (Kemetans/Egyptains) but explains thier entire system of spiritual cultivation, which includes "talking to the God" through a system of ORACLES, not unlike what Zakariah did when he was chosen to take care of Mary. But besides that, it breaks down the Spirit/Mind so scientifically, it brings out so much wisdom, in my opinion. I think the biggest thing that it helped me to do was to realize that it is BEHAVIOR Shaping that we are really dealing with, which this reading(quran) verifies.
  • Quran Only Organizations in Hong Kong and Singapore

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    22 Views
    R
    Hello, i myself went through all that is required of a convert to be to ?slam""by the govt of singapore, and now my wife is too. I remember marrying my wife via the civil ceremony and the local muslim authority making a fuss over it. We are into our 4th yr of marriage and everything''s is still fine between us. what matters is in your mind. Oh yeah, i remember seeing chinese non- muslim women newscasters wearing headscarves in some arab muslim countries but they still did not forget upon coming back home to eat thier favourite pork dish. i do not mean to offend - just to state as example. you have to make adjustments to keep yourself sane and safe BUT not to make compromises when it comes tofaith. Even to this i am still fighting off sunnis who get in the way. Hopefully one day we too will be accepted . God help us all
  • can meditation turn into shirk?

    8
    0 Votes
    8 Posts
    101 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you, What we have to remember is this, no matter what comes to your mind, wethere through a human being, or from something that you cannot determine if it is a thought, or intuition, we must STILL VERIFY IT IN LIFE If it is intuition from the ALL KNOWING who created us and resides within us, then the information will not contradict life and will help you solve your problems, false information will be rejected by this system(deen) of rigid laws. For example, a man once thought that the God told him thee was a "19" based miracle that was suppossed to show us that this reading , minus two verses, is "holy". So we have to always verify any information. There is no excuse of blind belief.
  • My New Site For The Community Of Betterment

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    219 Views
    U
    peace LT, Wakas is mistaken. No girl will wait for you while you feed your brain with knowledge! Unfortunately, I dont find it odd you are making wild assumptions in the justification of your comments. No girl in the world? Or perhaps rather, the exemplar of girl you identify with? Wakas Hello Wakas, Is a girl waiting for you while you feed your brain with knowledge from free minds? -) That lassie must be very patient girl !!! -) Don't worry Wakas, I was not making wild assumptions. It is called witticism chap, as in humour, as tongue-in-cheek saying, as a joke, a way of saying thing in a amusing way etc... so don't take it seriously -) Regards,
  • The prophets, and their miracles

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    50 Views
    S
    Peace all. Peace idolfree. I'm not sure about your question concerning where was another Moses for the Jews persecuted by Hitler or for people in Africa. If I in any way implied that one group of people was more deserving of rescue than another, my apologies. That was not my intention. I was addressing only the specific incident of parting the Red Sea. As to how Jesus healed the sick or for Moses touchng the sea with his staff and the waters parting, that goes to what I was trying to say (but obviously didn't quite do so very clearly ). Moses and Jesus didn't do those things on their own--God performed the miracles through them. God can do such things with ease, even if they are still on the edge of our "reason" and within our realm of comprehension, especially as we grow in knowledge. It's as if we are allowed to glimpse the inner workings of some things without necessarily being able to duplicate the results or, at least, duplicate them without a lot of effort. But this much I do know--we must first know that something can be done before we can begin to try it on our own. Awareness happens when God does something extraordinary for humans to witness. Perhaps miracles are a way for us to know, when we are ready, what wonderful things can be achieved. Webster's defines "miracle" as "an extraordinary event manifesting divine intervention in human affairs" or "an extremely outstanding or unusual event, thing, or accomplishment." While the definition of "miracle" may stay the same, our definition of "extraordinary event" changes as our knowledge increases. Our ability to understand concepts evolves and we learn in stages, according to what our minds can accept. I had to learn classical physics before studying quantum mechanics and relativity. And people who went on to grad school know far more than I do. You slid in their the statement "and tales of such events are accurate", how so? Were are these events rerpoduced? I am sure all of the religious and non religious world for that matter would pay to see these events reenacted, but it just doesn't happen. These events will always stay hidden in some lab because sticks don't EVER turn into snakes. And man will never fly or travel to the moon or harness the power of the atom. Yesterday's lab experiments currently light our homes, keep them warm or cool, and allow us to travel to all parts of the globe with relative ease, as well as venture beyond our planet's atmosphere. If I were to travel back in time and try to explain nuclear fission to someone who hadn't yet learned to start a fire whenever they pleased, I'd be considered crazy. They couldn't understand what a lightbulb is, much less the need for electricity. So what purpose would there be for trying to manipulate an atom--something which can't be seen. Quite impractical for people to pursue such a fantastical tale, much less believe what I was saying. Overall, we tend to develop knowledge that will be used in some way...articles of convenience for a time. They would, however, probably be intersted if I were to use my Bic and start a campfire in seconds. But how would I adequately explain such a thing? For a simple dollar lighter, I'd first have to explain what plastic and metal and butane are. Then there'd be no way to duplicate that same lighter in the Stone Age. Ah, but the good thing might be that in lighting the fire, I could possibly "spark" the imagination of a Stone Age scientist who realized fire could indeed be harnessed and put to good use as needed, which begins the process of discovery. (And don't get me into a causality argument here--it's just a very simplistic example.) So perhaps it would take a tremendous explanation, involving basic concepts we don't yet understand, to explain to us how to turn an ordinary staff into a snake. And it seems we've yet to find a practical use for such a skill. Therefore, mankind will have to wait patiently until the day when "sticks-to-snakes" are within our realm of understanding. Even if that day should ever come, once again, it's very likely we would only be able to duplicate the action with considerable effort and expense. Still, we have an example of when such a thing occurred, so we can see that it's possible. We may not always be able to duplicate such feats, which God does with ease, but they are understandable in some cases. Well than Santa Clause and the Easter Bunny can also be understandable using that basis. They just don't duplicate such feats all the time for everyone. Once we learn how to do certain things, we get better at them. I have more memory storage capacity in my tiny MP3 player than the biggest computer made at the dawn of that era. Therefore, it's quite conceivable to me that God, in His inifinte Power and Wisdom, can work miracles through His prophets with ease...for the benefit of those who need such miracles at that time, as well as providing us with examples of what is within the realm of possibiities. (As for pursuing what we have no knowledge of, I tend to think that applies to matters of pure speculation--such as the number of years the people and the dog were in the cave.) Finally (yes, Virginia, there is a "finally"), we don't have to talk about Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny. Instead, we could talk about quarks and neutrinos or maybe electron clouds and quantum jumps...or superstring theory, where there's plenty to challenge the mind and stretch the boundaries of human reason.
  • The Holy Viruses of Brain

    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    14 Views
    U
    Peace Edip, A brilliant article, it certainly struck a chord with me. The verses you provided and many other relating to knowledge, following what your parents told you is a testament that the Qur'an advocates rationality, independent thought with uncompromising objectivity. The Qur'an has the antidote of any false system that we are born into, with the Qur'an our minds are purified, provided we choose the path of GOD. I was born into a sunni system full of unspeakable corruptions, now I feel I have been born again and my eyes have just barely opened, I am very much at the begining of my quest for the reality of GOD. My only issue with the article would be that the opening arguments sounded more of muslim tradition as opposed to a christian, I don't know whether christians reason that way, since I don't ask them. But you could be right. Meanwhile, it is not uncommon to hear traditional muslims speak this way. Peace
  • someone was arguing with me from here

    17
    0 Votes
    17 Posts
    145 Views
    I
    peace be upon you AP, I wonder if tharilist has been reading albion's newsposts... lol well I guess Damon's theory turned out right after all
  • Acting .. (Showbiz)

    43
    0 Votes
    43 Posts
    660 Views
    A
    hehehe yeah i thought Taj was a girls name as well ... hehehe sorry )
  • Articles on Free-Minds ..

    16
    0 Votes
    16 Posts
    145 Views
    U
    I think this word "scholar" has cause enough to create blind believers and make ppl dependent on these so called scholars. The idea is that you should not rely on any single man for your information. You should have access to all the available information and then draw up your own conclusions. Never be dependent on any one Scholar. They are human beings. They are fallible as you are. The onus is on you to use your God-given reason to derive your own understandings... Regards,
  • CENSORSHIP

    17
    0 Votes
    17 Posts
    40 Views
    S
    Peace, I have opened this topic so that we can discuss this important issue on censorship. How far can Free Minds go in regards to censorship? We should only be restricting ourselves by what God and His messenger have restricted us. Freedom of religion/faith is allowed according to God's Scripture. So is open debate and the exchange of different views no matter how opposite (e.g. Noah and his people, or Abraham and the king). What is restricted is slander, calling names, backbiting, or any other such despicable acts as outlined in the Scripture. agree with you bro..)
  • Vote for da Biiiiiiiiibllllllllllle!!!!!!!!!!

    18
    0 Votes
    18 Posts
    33 Views
    F
    I must say though, it's interesting to see the direction this thread has taken... pretty much like all other threads here. The beginning, simple and straight-forward... as it "progresses", it slowly deviates to a different level, by the end of it, I doubt if it will have any resemblance to what Saladin intended. roll hmm... has it ever "progressed" as intended ?! roll
  • Brad Pitt Interview on Poverty

    23
    0 Votes
    23 Posts
    337 Views
    S
    Peace all, I agree with sytalls excellent post... Plus, I strongly feel that we have no real control over the outcome. We do our best, try to be reasonable and logical about giving to a program or organization that has a good reputation, then leave the rest to God. God could easily provide for every person on earth out of His Bounty. Instead, he enlarges or restricts individual provisions, and He tests our willingness to part with what He's given us. Maybe we can wipe out poverty altogether and maybe we can't...but I think our duty lies in the striving to do so not in trying to control the outcome. That is the same approach i use...imo save the children is a good site, it gives a good breakdown and you can check up on what their activities have been during the past year, it used to have a better interface a couple years ago when you could donate to specific areas but that has changed a bit in the last year...as Zein noted in his post... Anyway, whatever you choose... there's a big element of trust involved... does the person in need, actually get what they need? Well, we could sit here and contemplate on that and have an excuse... or we could actually do something. Well said...i completely agree.
  • Help me Out on this other forum ...

    12
    0 Votes
    12 Posts
    122 Views
    S
    you should ask very simple questions...) They think movies to be haram but they all watch it..LOL they think music is haram according to hadith but thats a music forum..LOL Picture is haram according to hadith but most of them have avatars of humans....LOL As they follow so much sunnah than would anyone in that forum marry off their sisters at the age of six ? Do they drink camel urine ? Do they stone the monkies ? ( they should do it for the sake of sunna copycat) Trading slaves ? war booty ? what not.... well the best thing is if the angels aer able to enter earths atmosphiere..?? LOL u know, the world is saturated with pictures of living beings..LOL peace