Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.2k Topics 133.2k Posts
  • Muslims' opinions needed

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    18 Views
    M
    Dear All, I am the founder of the Murtads from Malaysia website (http//www.geocities.com/murtad_malaysia/). I personally think that Islam could be interpreted and practiced in very tolerant way. Islam doesn't need to be forced onto people like what is done in Malaysia. I have a concern that when people come across my website, people would think all Muslims are intolerant which is of course not true. So, I am considering putting up quotes by tolerant Muslims on the website and I need your help. Would you be willing to help out? What I need you to do is send me an email to [email protected] with your answers to these questions. In one sentence or two, state your opinion on what the Malaysian government is doing (forcing people who don?t want to be Muslims to be Muslims)? In one sentence or two, state your opinion about religious freedom and tolerance in Islam. In one sentence or two, state your opinion on faith rehabilitations centers for Muslim Apostates. In one sentence or two, state your opinion on the death penalty for Muslim Apostates. In one sentence or two, state your opinion about Muslims sending hate emails to Former Muslims. Do you think Muslims should be given more rights than others? Explain your answer in one sentence. What name or pseudonym you would like to use to go along with your opinions online? What is your country of residence (optional)? Thank you for giving Islam a good name and reducing the stigma Muslims face in places where they are the minority! wink
  • Quran's Initials

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    42 Views
    T
    Peace I hear that the Quran's initials are abbreviations for words. In the translation of Maulana Muhammad Ali has for example in chapter 2 I, Allah, am the best Knower. These initials must have a clear - cut meaning. Joe
  • 29:14

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    37 Views
    T
    Peace All What are the meanings of 'aaman' and 'sanaatin'? Joe
  • Original/Earliest Quran

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    6 Views
    U
    I brought this topic up earlier on before my posting mysteriously disappeared ! I am eager to find the earliest dated complete quran. Reason being that I want to be absolutely certain that the widely available copies now bear resemblance to the earliest copies. Using the quran, I see that there is a verse stating that Muhamad wrote the quran himself and hence was not illiterate and I can accept this. I also noticed Anwar Goins quoting a verse were it directs Muhamad to 'arrange the quran excellently'. That being said, first of all, there exist, as far as I know, differences between certain texts. I have heard of some qurans being called 'Hafs' and 'Warsh'. I have read articles about these explaining that these differences do not actually change the meaning of the verses. I am willing to accept this - however, given the above, why do any differences exist in the first place? Secondly, at submission.org, the link below shows some differences between the Tashkent Quran in Uzbek and the readily available quran copies today. http//www.submission.org/quran/protect.html The Tashkent Quran is quite old, but I am not sure if it is the oldest around. Although the webpage highlights the differences for other purposes , once again, differences clearly exist. I realise that the differences don't seem to make too much of a difference but yet again, given the statements from the quran quoted about Muhamad's literacy and arranging of the quran excellently, why have these differences occured? Here is another link to a site that claims this is the oldest Quran copy http//faculty.washington.edu/wheelerb/quran/kufi_393.html This topic is vitally important if we are to uphold the intergrity of the Word. I think it is desriable to find out how and why these differences came about and search for the oldest quran copy. According to tradition the quran was compiled by Uthman the Caliph right? Well how did this tradition begin in the first place if the quran was already there when Muhamad had written it and arranged it? I hope that God guides us to the truth on this roll
  • Should people who live together pray together?

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    30 Views
    J
    One might ask Should people who live together pray together? What do you all here think about that? I bet the orthodox way would reject anyone NON muslim in the househod to begin with but at salat times should people pray together, like one leads them into prayer? or should they do prayers whenever the moment they start theres? Thanks
  • WELCOME ALL!

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    7 Views
    LaythL
    Peace, A massive 'Thank You' for Rice who has spent the last 2 days in the hell of moving this forum with its content!. I don't know how you finally managed...but Thank You. Layth
  • Al Muhajiroun needs to be stopped

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    24 Views
    P
    http//www.obm.clara.net/pr/2003/911.html Two years on then, it seems that during their customary 1 minutes silence in NewYork and elsewhere on September the 11th 2003, Muslims worldwide will again be watching replays of the collapse of the Twin Towers, praying to Allah (SWT) to grant those magnificent 19, Paradise. They will also be praying for the reverberations to continue until the eradication of all man-made law and the implementation of divine law in the form of the Khilafah - carrying the message of Islam to the world and striving for Izhar ud-Deen i.e. the total domination of the world by Islam. OMG, I swear I wish I was in London. I would choke their throats and murder them like the scum they are. I am still baffled about how Muslims stay silent when idiots like them keep spilling out this virolic garbage. If anybody is in London, please do me a favor and beat the living crap out of these scumbags. They are nothing but a waste of skin and a disgrace to Islam.
  • Dead Sea Scroll Prophecy

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    12 Views
    D
    Woodstock and Dead Sea Scroll Connections(believe it or not) I make attempt to make money from my site. People should be aware. http//www.woodstockanddeadseascrolls.net/
  • " THE ARAB CONSPIRACIES AGAINST AL-ISLAM"...

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    14 Views
    U
    Salaamun alaikum I've recently been reading the article "The Arab Conspiracies Against Al-Islam" by Aidid Safar. http//www.free-minds.org/Arab_Conspiracy.html This is a MUST read article, because in my opinion, he has thoroughly proven these things no such thing as 5 daily ritual prayers (so-called salaa). Salaa, really means committments, obligations, responsibilities, etc. zakaa has nothing to do with money (2.5%). Zakaa, really means to purify one's salaa. there is no such thing as "pilgrimage" to Mecca. the Kaba, is a stone idol, making it, the most successful idol in the world. the Arabs purposely mistranslated the Qur-an to lead people away from Allah and His Din. What I have discovered from other sources is that, there is no such thing as ALLAHU AKBAR in the Qur-an and it is SHIRK to say it. Would like your feedback on these issues, insha-Allah, because it is apparent to me that, either he's right and the current practices of Muslims are not or he's wrong and the current practices are correct. What do you think? And please, no just blowing him off as a kaffir or other such anti-intellectual remarks, thanks. Dhulqarnain- PS If this subject has been discussed before, please point me to thread so that I can read the arguements, thanks again.
  • Please give me your honest answer, new to Islam

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    27 Views
    J
    Hello Can people explain the basics of Islam here
  • Should I Know This?

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    7 Views
    U
    Peace y'all. I'm a new member of the family. I just joined two days ago. I have a question that I hope will not make me look stupid or something. What does it mean when I'm reading something by someone on different topics of this forum and they'll have &#8212 written in there? Am I missing something? ?
  • What happens after death?

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    30 Views
    I
    Peace all, So, what happens in the stage between death and the day of judgement? When a person dies, does time become irrelevant, therefore making the DOJ momentary after death. I ask this since the belief in ghosts and the such would mean that the soul resides on earth even after death and it would be obvious that the body cannot be resurected until the actual DOJ. So between death and the DOJ what happens to the soul? I hope that my question is clear
  • Homosexuality?

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    14 Views
    O
    Peace, everyone. I'm new to the boards, so let me introduce myself. I'm a college student, living in the Third World, and recently came out to myself as a lesbian. I'm not a Muslim, but I do know a fair bit about Islam. I have also read the Quran. I know about the whole Sunnah-Hadith issue. I most definitely am not anti-Islam, but I do not believe. I am an agnostic. I would like to know what place homosexuality has in Islam. I understand the story of Sodom in the Quran, but I also realize that it is a bit vague and some people claim it is about homosexual rape. I also understand that there is an online Queer Jihad being carried out. I would like to know what the Free-Minds members think about all of this. With same-sex marriages recently being made legal in Canada (following Netherlands and Belgium), obviously homosexuality is on its way to acceptance, although we still have a long way to go. Religion, in my opinion, is one of the major obstacles, because all the world's major religions condemn homosexuality (although many Christian churches have 'adapted' or 'reinterpreted' religion to reconcile it with homosexuality). This condemnation is tragic, because most of us have had feelings of same-sex attraction since we were kids (myself, since I was twelve) and it has taken us a long time to accept ourselves because of the shame we associated with those feelings. If you believe that homosexuality is unnatural or a form of pathology, please back up your statements with research (although I'll be shocked if anyone can disprove or refute decades of peer-reviewed research). Otherwise, I'd appreciate it if you'd refrain from making bigoted remarks about homosexuals. Mainly, I'm just trying to see what spectrum of opinions I can find among Muslims on this topic. I'm not looking to start a fight. Frankly, I'm not interested in discussing the causes of homosexuality (a pointless debate...once sexuality is shaped, it's shaped, regardless of the causes) or reorientation therapy (which the APA has issued cautionary statements about). Thank you.
  • A call to all muslim scientists and science students

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    28 Views
    T
    Salaam All, As a brief intro I will say the following- I am a muslim currently doing an engineering degree, in a few years I hope to do a phd in genetics (insha Allah). I have a great inetrest in studying the signs of Allah all around us and within us. In my many, many, hours of reading on science I have noticed a very bad problem. Scientists take as an axiomtic bases, the denial of God and his action in the universe. This is called methodological naturalism, materialism. These are the people who distort data according to their prejudices and propagate it to the masses as science, these masses include many willing and accepting muslims. 'Progressive muslims' are within this catagory unfortunately... It is time to make the qur'an our guide, our furqaan in the way we see the world. I have not explained myself fully because I am currently at work.. But feel free to ask questions... Basically what I want from this posting is the following. Every muslim who is a scientist (of any kind), please make yourself known along with your field and qualification. Every muslim who is doing a science degree (of any kind, bio, chem, phys, math etc...), please make yourself known along with what degree you are doing. I believe a project of great importance can be begun if there are muslims, ready, willing and able... Please make yourself known (Pseudoname will do, we can contact via email if required) Salaam.
  • This news article pisses me off

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    21 Views
    P
    Hearing to Open in Muslim ID Dispute Mon May 26, 820 PM ET Add U.S. National - AP to My Yahoo! ORLANDO, Fla. - A Muslim woman is going to court against the state this week in her fight to wear a veil that covers most of her face for her driver's license photo. Sultaana Freeman sued the state of Florida after it revoked her license because she refused to replace the photo with one showing her face uncovered. Freeman, 35, argues the state violated her right to freedom of religion by demanding the new photo. The state contends that allowing a photo of a hidden face puts public safety at risk. Her attorney, Howard Marks, said Freeman believes that taking a photograph of her face uncovered would violate the Quran, the Muslim holy book. Jason Vail, an assistant attorney general, said police officers use driver's license photos for many things, such as helping to identify criminals, missing persons and crime victims. Marks said Freeman received the state's demand that she retake her photo three months after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Vail denied any connection between the two events. How ridiculous is this? She is so stupid and ignorant that she really believes that taking the veil off would violate the Qu'ran. Has anyone managed to put some sense into this stupid woman's head that covering yourself is not obligatory in Islam? Man this kind of stuff pisses me off, when idiots like this woman fight in court with our taxpayer money for something as ridiculous as this. If she insists on wearing a veil, I suggest she should move to Saudi Arabia and then she will treated the way she wants to be. I'm sorry for the rant, but stuff like this pisses me off. If she doesn't want to integrate, then she should get out! Its idiots like her that give us a bad name.
  • President Needs To Hear You.

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    15 Views
    A
    Peace, respectfully. Since there are no mosques in Slovenia, they are not allowed in this country, i would like to ask all of you to send an email, if you can and want, to the president of Slovenia (Danilo Turk) and ask him why, why are mosques prohibited from existing in Slovenia? He will most likely tell you that Muslims there (47.000 sunnis) are allowed to pray and that Islam is not prohibited there but the mosques don't exist there and then of course he will mention terrorism and 9/11, UBL and i would like you to engage in a long conversation with him because he is not the one who runs the country - catholic church is, the priests are running the show. This is the email of the president of Sovenija [email protected] This interestes me seriously because i'm a citizen there but what interests me more is their reaction after nonSlovene-citizens ask them this. Thank you and God bless you. Glory be to God. Peace.
  • The Basic FATAL error among the believers

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    11 Views
    R
    In The Name of GOD. The Clarifier of confusion. There are a few people whom The GOD has blessed to teach us HIS Way. Yet, most, Never got the lesson. Muhammad Ali. Bruce Lee. Both Spiritualists. They were Allowing The GOD, to Express their Soul via their Body. However, delicatess requires noticing what People fall short of from The Commands of The GOD. Muhamamd Ali was too cocky. i am, i am, each second word. To Truly Realized, the deepest level of the Soul, i am becomes The GOD is. so there is no i am, ONLY The GOD is. And HE is, Everywhere. Teaching HIS folks, and little thanks is sent back to the Source. Bruce Lee, was more Spiritualy Realized than Ali. Check his Interviews in youtube. Notice he was teaching folks to attain the Presence of the GOD. Hence, Again, Express the Soul, in the Presence of The GOD. as The ONLY way. Then, what happened? Whom GOD Glorifies none can stop, so they became stars. Millions of eyes seeing what their mind couldn'g comprehend. And giving Credit Only to what they were seeing. And Hearing. This is The GREATEST TEST. The Same Happened with Prophets, may GOD Bless Them With the Beyond Infinite BEST Only The GOD Can Provide. They were the Most Precise Tools of The GOD. And Whoever Lived in Their presence, wittnesed a Beyond Genius with their eyes. By GOD's Definition. The Problems started when The GOD Took them. And the mass screwed the system. Because they didn't keep the Responsibility of Cleaning. And whoever is not Responsible for what sees, hears and thinks, quickly becomes vulnerable to the forces dark, among The GOD's Creation. the devil is True to his Creation. He lives his Reponsibility, and never ceases to manipulate all humans among the lost on their forests of dellusion. So what happened is all this separation that we witness. Have folks been clean, they'd praise The GOD, for the Opportunity, to learn, from Whom The ALL Learning Comes. The GOD is the First station of the Mind of the Blessed. Try this. Look at something directly. Then Look at is Through The GOD. Via The GOD. What is the difference? Do this when you talk with people, and notice, become aware, Let The GOD Teach you HIS Way. Our INFINITY. The Eternal. When i am, becomes The GOD is, the Communion is re-established. When The Compliment becomes Communion. You are who you were meant to be. When the mind sees. The Light of All Universes. One Realizes where ALL Compliments belong. Never put the Trust to GOD's Creation. Put ALL your trust in The GOD. ANd Let HIM Manage it, where it need to be present. How many dissapointments happen becuse people trust GOD's Creation? People Plan to fail with their Own Mind. If they'd clean, The GOD would Include them in HIS Plan. The Greatest Purpose of The Life. Do not be of those who set partners with The GOD. Because the GOD wants us to Live HIS Expectation. In HIS Likeness he created the human. and the Friendship, Relationship, Communion, Annihilation with HIM provides the True and Real Meaning of the Life. Praise GOD that HE Has Created Everything that we are not to be attached to. Attach your self to The GOD. And Love HIS Creation, Through HIM. And kill the devil, by Communing with The GOD. It is the ONLY Way. And devils are Powerless creatures in the Presence of the ALLMighty on the Glorious Throne. It is The GOD. The GOD. The GOD. ALL. HIS. Peace, R.H.-Ustahi
  • One Must be Knowledgeable of the Qur'an to be a Due Servant of Allah

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    39 Views
    S
    One Must be Knowledgeable of the Qur'an to be a Due Servant of Allah The Qur'an is the Revelation of Allah and is the only Book that explains to believers the true meaning of faith. It is the only Book which explains to people the attributes of Allah, the favors of Allah and the way of Allah in dealing with disbelieving people, which are the kind of people the believer should not be. Only through the study of the Qur'an can one ever know how to be a due servant of Allah - any other definition of a believer is bound to be distorted. The Qur'an explains the life beyond the existing world, the nature of death, and the Day of Judgment. All matters of guidance have been explained in detail so that the Believers may take lessons from them and conduct themselves according to them. By way of reflecting on the Qur'anic Verses, the true believer increases in his or her faith in Allah and the reality of the Hereafter, an attribute of a true believer stated in the following Verse "Believers are they whose hearts tremble with awe whenever Allah is mentioned, and when His Verses are recited to them they increase them in faith and on their Sustainer they depend." (Qur'an 82) Without exploring the Qur'an regularly, the human soul begins to loose its true nearness to Allah. This is the unfortunate state of anyone who does not explore the Qur'an but chooses to remain distant from it including all disbelievers. When the Believer listens to or reads the Qur'an, he feels closer to the ever-present mercy and protection of Allah over him and his heart surrenders to Allah. His vision is sharpened as he is reminded of the details of the Hereafter and the greatness of Allah, as well as the way he should view and respond to worldly affairs that Allah creates around him. His becomes confident in his purpose in life and reassured that this world is temporary and has flaws. The nearer he is drawn to Allah, the more his desire is to study what Allah has to say in the Qur'an, and the more he studies the Qur'an, the nearer he is to Allah. This a positive circle of interdependent improvement of both Qur'anic wisdom and faith in Allah by which believers attain the highest level of true uprightness in this world, and the Paradise of Allah in the Hereafter. One can see that faith in Allah and having Qur'anic knowledge are related concepts. One cannot attain true faith in Allah if he does not understand the Qur'an, and without true faith one cannot properly understand the Qur'an. This means it is Allah who initiates the path of guidance for whoever He pleases "This (Qur'an) is a reminder. Let whoever wishes, take the way to his Lord. But you will only wish to do so if Allah wills. Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise." (Qur'an 7630) Believers have a deep connection with the Qur'an. This is because they love and fear Allah and the Qur'an is the only Book where Allah communicates to them. What is of utmost importance right now, is that all readers loose no time in making a sincere effort to begin making steps on this virtuous cycle of continuous spiritual enlightenment, guided by Allah's Book. This can be done only by being sincere and by seeking Allah's help while studying all the Verses of the Qur'an in light of one another. "This Qur'an guides to that which is most right" Once Allah begins to enlighten the soul, keep on this course of Qur'anic reflection and increase in faith, and do not waver from it. If anyone takes on such a path, then by Allah's permission he or she will soon discover a path most sublime and noble, and will be on his way to becoming a true believer, and be deserving of the Paradise of Allah.
  • MOVED: At what age should one start praying ?

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    34 Views
    T
    This topic has been moved to Salat & Zakat (The Contact & Purification). http//free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=16820.0
  • Mulla Nasruddin - The Wise Fool

    1
    0 Votes
    1 Posts
    28 Views
    P
    Anyone come across this genius whoever he/they maybe before? Nevertheless enjoy Delivering a Khutba Once, Nasreddin was invited to deliver a khutba. When he got on the minbar (pulpit), he asked "Do you know what I am going to say?" The audience replied "NO", so he announced "I have no desire to speak to people who don't even know what I will be talking about" and he left. The people felt embarrassed and called him back again the next day. This time when he asked the same question, the people replied "YES". So Nasreddin said, "Well, since you already know what I am going to say, I won't waste any more of your time" and he left. Now the people were really perplexed. They decided to try one more time and once again invited the Mullah to speak the following week. Once again he asked the same question - "Do you know what I am going to say?" Now the people were prepared and so half of them answered "YES" while the other half replied "NO". So Nasreddin said "The half who know what I am going to say, tell it to the other half" and he left! Two sides of a river Nasreddin sat on a river bank when someone shouted to him from the opposite side "Hey! how do I get to the other side?" "You are on the other side!" Nasreddin shouted back. Whom do you trust A neighbour comes to the gate of Mulla Nasreddin's yard. The Mulla goes out to meet him outside. "Would you mind, Mulla," the neighbour asks, "lending me your donkey today? I have some goods to transport to the next town." The Mulla doesn't feel inclined to lend out the animal to that particular man, however; so, not to seem rude, he answers "I'm sorry, but I've already lent him to somebody else." Suddenly the donkey can be heard braying loudly behind the wall of the yard. "You lied to me, Mulla!" the neighbour exclaims. "There it is behind that wall!" "What do you mean?" the Mulla replies indignantly. "Whom would you rather believe, a donkey or your Mulla?" Two Questions (retold by Nasruddin) It came to be that I was a mulla. This was when I was much younger. Now a mulla is an interesting job. A mulla is a teacher, a preacher, and a judge. I studied the Q'uran, and became quite familiar with the Sharia, the traditional Islamic laws, and began my time as a mulla in a little village in a far corner of the country. Now a mulla is considered a wise man, and for some reason, the villagers considered me one. They would ask me questions concerning aspects of their lives in which I was not expert at all. "Oh, Mulla Nasruddin, please tell me what I should do about my daughter!" "I'm sorry, sister, but you must work that out for yourself. I don't have a daughter, so I cannot tell you anything useful." "Mulla Nasruddin! My business is in terrible trouble! What should I do?" "Brother,you see I don't have a business, so I cannot tell you anything useful." "But you are such a wise man, Mulla Nasruddin! Please help me, please!" "All right, here's what you should do..." "Yes? Yes?" the man asked eagerly. "Pray to Allah for wisdom." He was not so happy with this answer. I think he had already tried that and found that Allah no matter how much wisdom Allah provided, he would not be able to do much with it himself. Finally the situation got completely out of hand. People began to pester me with questions night and day. I was sleeping in the starlight on my roof, and a pebble hit me on the forehead. On reflection, it was more of a stone than a pebble. I feared it might have done permanent damage. I looked over the edge, and there in the street was a man looking up. "Mulla Nasruddin, are you asleep?" "I find it hard to sleep when stones are falling from Heaven," I said. "It was only a little pebble, Mulla, besides, I have a question." "Brother, it is the middle of the night!" "My question is very important, or I would not have disturbed you. Please come down and we can discuss it." "Just give me the gist of it, and I'll ponder it on my way down." "I need to know, Mulla Nasruddin, should I tell a prospective buyer that my donkey is sick?" "I don't need to come down for that one. Of course you should! Honesty is required of you. And as it is also required of me, I tell you honestly that question could have waited till morning; go home!" So it was, day and night, I couldn't even brush my teeth without being interrupted with questions. I brandished my miswak, my tooth-brushing twig, but somehow no one was frightened. Finally I hit upon a solution. Beside my door I put a sign that said in large letters, "Two questions for $100." Peace at last! Days went by with no questions; it was lovely. But finally a rich man came to my door with a bag of gold hanging from his belt. "Nasruddin!" he called out. I came to the door. "May I help you?" "You are fortunate today," he said. "I have plenty of money." "You are the fortunate one,"I replied. "I can afford your two questions," he said, and raised one eyebrow. I have always wished I could do that. "So we are both fortunate," I said . "Indeed," the man said. "But, don't you think one hundred dollars is a little expensive for just two questions?" "Yes it is," I replied. "And what is your second question?"