Skip to content

General Issues / Questions

This area deals with any general questions/issues regarding God / Islam / Quran not covered under other headings.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

7.1k Topics 133.0k Posts
  • Would my fellow Muslims dare answer these rational questions?

    75
    0 Votes
    75 Posts
    2k Views
    L
    Salaam Bros n Sisters, Its been a long time since I posted. As a rational monotheist Muslim, I am content that I follow a religion that is most logical and superior to all other beliefs on Earth. But then there are yet questions about Islam that bother me. These are questions that pop-up when discussing religion with people of other religions. I would be grateful if all of you here could provide your own views and responses. Shukran. Here are a few queries.... We usually discuss that the Holy Quran is very scientific, logical and one will not find any nonsense within it. But then we also have verses that discuss about King Solomon's time when he 'spoke' to the hoopoe bird and heard the ant; when 'jinns' did all kinds of magical stuff in daily life. Verses talk about the bad effects of black-magic, the evil-eye etc. all of which are truly unscientific. Hindus are quick to point out such verses to show that their outlandish mythologies of demons and gods on earth are comparatively the same in this regard. On what basis can one invite a rational polytheist/ disbeliever/ pagan/ athiest to 'believe' Islam when we have to ask him to accept our unbelievable stories, so as to leave behind his own illogical beliefs? If Islam is the true word of God, why is there so much chaos, suffering and hatred in the Muslim world? If we explain that this is because average Muslims do not follow the real word of God from the Quran, then the Christian asks, why then did God reveal the Quran, if people ultimately did not follow it? What is the utility of the revelation when it is not used for society's benefits? Why is it that the world's most peaceful, techonologically advanced and democratic countries that give human freedoms are all nations that DO NOT follow the message of Islam? For whose benefit was the "final message" of the Quran revealed? For just a few individuals here and there who call themselves monotheists? What is the need for the message, when mankind is always attaining its ethical and moral goals through other sources? We say the Bible is not truly the word of God, but contains conflicting messages. How is it that the adherents of the Bible, even today are the most blessed of all people,the most charitable and the most powerful? They have established schools, hospitals and orphanages across the world, with countless priests and nuns having dedicated their lives for the welfare of the needy. How many Muslims organisations are doing half of this work? Something as basic as marriage..if it is allowed by God to have up to 4 wives for men, (assuming that one can be just and fair to each wife) why is it that the Prophet of Islam had upto 9 wives at the same time? Isn't the very messenger, breaking the message he preached? Isn't that hypocrisy? Any answers to these queries would really make life a lot easier.. Thank you so much for your time! Peace. http//queriesonislam.files.wordpress.com/2011/07/alquran-4-1-1_wordpress.gif?w=620&h=465 Assalamu aleykum Answering to your first question, we have first of all, like you have mentioned yourself, listen to what logic dictates. You have to know that, for example in legal system we have what we call primary evidence and secondary evidence. If you make a claim like? ?we also have verses that discuss about King Solomon's time when he 'spoke' to the hoopoe bird and heard the ant?, then you want to deal with the secondary evidence, disregarding the primary one, which is completely illogical. Consequently, once you have come with such a claim, it becomes up to you to first disprove the primary evidence (unless it is not available), which is the Qur?an. One is not in a position to respond to a claim which is based on something no more than convenient for the one making statement. Once we?ve answered the first question, then the second is actually of no use. But once again, wherever you come with a claim, you have to make sure, that you are actually based on something. For example, ?why are there so much chaos, suffering and hatred in the Muslim world? how do you define ?Muslim World?? Government?s self-declaration of ruling under religious law, the establishment of an official state religion, or more than 50 percent of the population practicing, or claiming to belong to, a particular religion, etc. ? Suffering due to what? And many other questions. You see, once the question is addressed one can begin to claim empirically whether, for example, Islam deters or enhances social and economic development. So once again, it?s your turn to prove your claims in the first place. It concerns every single one of your questions, for which you haven?t given evidences. Example ?How is it that the adherents of the Bible, even today are the most blessed of all people?- ?the most charitable? ?and the most powerful?? ?They have established schools hospitals and orphanages across the world with countless priests and nuns having dedicated their lives for the welfare of the needy.? ?How many Muslims organizations are doing half of this work?? These all claims are for you to prove, before we can have a serious conversation, based on evidence. If a person is claiming to be rational and logical, then he ought to follow the laws of logic, and one could get the discussion further, unless he is based on speculations. Once again, what is your premise? You have to disprove the Quran is from God for us to proceed with that statement. I hope that it gave you an idea of how to deal with all these questions on a rational level, and showed you how speculative are the claims you made without any prove. Consequently, well-grounded arguments, proves and evidences are the integral part of a fair discussion. God bless Assalamu aleykum wa rahmatu-llahi wa barakatuh
  • Human vs Jinn Powers

    34
    0 Votes
    34 Posts
    445 Views
    D
    Peace drfazl, The Jinn spirit indulge in the flesh and you would say that the doctors you propagate against in your thread about "MM" are Jinns Brother, Man of Faith Nice to hear that back again from other than me. God bless all. If we die and are assimilated in Allah while departing, then it is a blessing. Every assimilated person looks forward to the day they die, so better live spiritually and let ourselves die if we contract a disease if this is the Rabb's will than pervert ourselves in the flesh. HumdAllah. We have to stop thinking fleshly. Allah speaks of spiritual affinity and not of flesh or concretely. The whole universe is Allah's design in flesh and it will all be over in a flash; and about the flesh - these creations are there as visible to or invisible to man's naked knowledge; mann is placed as the highest manifestations of such creations in flesh, with a fixed life term in the fleshy universal habitat. The philosophies, concepts, ideas, theses and facts and figures are born out of this fleshy brainstorming think-tanks. You are right, we should stop this fleshy thinking. I fully endorse it. The mann, the mind of man must cleave asunder the universal atmosphere and shall enter the space, from where the entire universe is created, to explore the creative powers where only Allah is our Guide, Enricher, Provider. Though the mann is living within this fleshy universe on the earth below the seven firmaments, he is bound to gain his liveliness from the spaciousness of God endowed Creative Powers of the Space, beyond universes. And the other fleshy creation on par with the men is that who is invisible to man's sight, the creation of Jinn. And they too have the brute fleshy powers like the brain of men. Of the two, man has more subtle, yet most powerfully enlivening mind created by God to have their say over the universal nature, if only the mann uses the God given wisdom, his mind, to gain superiority over the brainstorm. Our whole life shall involve in disgracing the fleshy knowledge of the brain, and in enriching the mind to cross the seven heavens to enter the spacious life in space. Our fleshy body shall remain in the world while our minds individually explore the heavens for the splendorous life of its flesh on the earth as a Sign unto the mankind. In this way we shall lead a life of honour and dignity in this world and in the world next with flesh and mind together with mind ever gaining mastery, by the leave of Allah. Have you not heard of latest news reports of people who wake up in the grave or when they have declared someone as clinically dead in hospitals and they wake up after their heart has been silent for a long time. These are clear signs from Allah, but people still doubt about Allah, why? Hospitals are ghost infested grave yard structures. People and patients dread to go there and they are dead alive in it. The ebola scare they spread with such orchestration around the world is dead and gone with the wind already; this is God's grace that the spread of another ghost disease is decimated. salam
  • After death and next life

    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    52 Views
    J
    I saw a dream or it is more likely a nightmare that I feel and am pretty sure my eyes were wide open and i could see my wife sleeping next to me on the other end of the bed. I see in my dream, that I am talking to my wife and kids in the same room and then I open the window, and the street looks the same but there is some thing terribly wrong. I have this feeling that this is not my actual family and that am not in my home but another place and at that time it occurred to me that am dead and that i left my physical world and am now as a soul and the people around me are just to make me feel better but the real physical people (wife and kids) are in the actual room where i still would be sleeping dead and that my family would soon realize that i have died. At that moment i felt so strange and helpless that will i continue to go in this infinite dream life wandering here and there as a soul and meeting people that i knew in real life... is death really means that am in an endless dream... but i could feel so strong that i some how want to break away from this world and go back to my real life. At that moment i prayed to God and begged to give me one chance to go back to my real life and that i be good or better and do this and that etc etc. I kept doing it and suddenly my eyes(which were open and which were able to SENSE all this time that am also in the bed lying next to wife) suddenly blinks and i can feel an immediate some thing came into my body and i feel am now bck in my self. I then verify again and see wife sleeping. I woke up (was already as my eyes were open). stood up and wanted to realize what actually just happened. I went to the other side of bed and tried to wake up my wife softly, after some time she opened her eyes and was about to scream, what the hell am doing standing in this our. I said i had a dream and i was like dead and as i was about to tell more, she said, can we please talk about it the morning and i shud go back to sleep, kids have to go to school tomorrow and i have to wake up etc etc. I was sad and then i went to the other side of room, sat on the sofa and started to just imagine what has happened. After some time she realized and came and asked me what actually happened, i told her every thing and she said that it was a nightmare and nothing to worry about. She asked me what did i take before going to bed (as i was a bit sick with a bit of sore throat). I said I took 5 tablets of calcium and vitamin C at one as I felt so thirsty and i wanted miranda flavor drink. She said probably it is an over dosage and that my eyes were wide open due to the medicine. interesting dream, This documentary might be interesting for you National Geographic Paranatural Life After Life https//www.youtube.com/watch?v=pSfNSTB-Xd8 Many (not all) of those who has experienced "Near Death Experience" actually doesn't want to be 'alive' again and actually wanted to stay 'dead'.
  • How Should We Muslims View Assisted Suicide?

    14
    0 Votes
    14 Posts
    26 Views
    H
    There are extreme situations of suffering which I find ruthless and too daring to judge when one is not in it. From the outside we may think and speculate as much as we want, but we do not know. We are not the ones undergoing it. God tells as in an aya to ask Him not to burden us beyond our capacity, but however we ask, He may want to do just that or what is burden beyond our capacity? Is the limit set by our capacity to not commit suicide? We are all horrified by the sufferings inficted by criminals and torturers and at some time we stop looking or reading about those things because we cannot bear it. However the people we were undergoing that could not stop being in it, like we can stop thinking or reading about it. I really cannot say that somebody who wants suicide under a extreme situation has failed a test. To the best of my ability I do not think I would ever be able to say that. I am sure God is not unjust and in would not on top of it punish that person, but would be rahim and wadud to the sufferer of so much pain. I think that imagination in those cases does not give a clue to justice. I have certain misgivings as to make it legal, because of the abuses it might give cover to. However, without being legal I am sure it is being done because people prefer the risk of being discovered rather than see the suffering of somebody they ay love. Also it is done due to greed to people who might not want to commit suicide, but of course that comes under the common crimes. I think any laws on that kind of thing should be aimed at not punishing people for things we have no power over them or which escape our capacity to judge with justice and at the same time prevent abuse of any gap that might be left. Although even so, we know it perfectly, it is not laws that avoid crime but abiding by them what does it. The world is full of laws in many places which are very good, but which are not throughly applied, because people disregard them and there is no abiity or will to enforce them and they are useless. I do not think this domain of life and death should be made a matter of right or wrong, but rather acknowledge our own limits as humans and see that these extreme cases are not used to cover other cases that may be clear willful interested crimes. We are not God nor gods, and I feel that there are things with which God reminds us of our limits when disposing of things and living beings, we are doomed to knot know and have to act on best intentions. Salaam
  • A summary of Daniel Brown's book translated to Norwegian

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    13 Views
    T
    Peace brothers and sisters The link I added for the Norwegian translation of the summary/text in my last, doesn't work anymore. But I have created a new link with the summary/text of Daniel Brown's book. You can download the summary/text of Daniel Brown's book from this link https//www.dropbox.com/s/tlbhprz884cpfcj/Et%20sammendrag%20av%20boken%20Revurdering%20av%20Tradisjon%20i%20Moderne%20Islamsk%20Tenkning.pdf?dl=0
  • Who Was the Pharoah of Moses

    318
    0 Votes
    318 Posts
    18k Views
    F
    Salaam Pazuzu, This was a great research. It is making lots of sense. I have to verify some parts of it though. God bless you.
  • Did prophet Muhammad know the future? Quran answers

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    67 Views
    WakasW
    You have conveniently and subtly changed your position after I cornered you. Nope. You can substitute unseen with future if you wish, my argument is still the same Prophet Muhammad did not know the unseen/future. He, like anyone of us who has access to The Quran, has been TOLD about the unseen/future. He, like any one of us, do not KNOW it of our own selves. We are reliant upon God for this information. The occurrence of the Day of Judgment is an event that shall occur in the future. The fact that it shall occur some time in the future excludes it from being something that is Ghayb (Unseen). No it doesn't. Even if some event will definitely occur in the future it still remains unseen. Put simply you haven't literally seen (i.e. witnessed) the future, ergo, unseen. You have not qualified your absurd and ridiculous assertion by saying "The Prophet (peace be upon him) has only partial knowledge of what shall occur in the future". And so have we (as you pointed out earlier with your 'Day of Judgement' example). Thanks for showing that prophet Muhammad, in this regard, is like anyone else who has access to The Quran. ;D (And that was the point of my thread. You can phrase it any way you like, but pay close attention to the way I worded it.)
  • :: What to believe? ::

    55
    0 Votes
    55 Posts
    1k Views
    B
    Salaam, You are still the same > No changes > Salaam, Not true, I am older now yes I mean believing like believing in you or a computer or internet is OK. But if you don't believe in them you will go to hell. My question was believing as in blue, do we need to believe like this if we believe in Allah alone? Or believing in Allah alone is enough. It is hard not to believe in something which you have witnessed. If a messenger comes to me with a message from Allah, I will believe in both in Allah and in the messenger, how is it even possible to deny the messenger if you believe in his message? Would be strange to say "Yo messenger I totally belief in every word you had with you but I don't believe in you, I believe in Allah alone". Should we belief in things we have not witnessed? That's a more difficult question. I do not believe in angels like in the movies but I believe in malaikats, I do not know exactly what they are or who they are are but I believe in a book which mentions to my idea some creatures called malaikats so I do believe in them even without knowing exactly what or who they are. May Allah bless you pr mmKhan May Allah bless you 2 pr Bender I have the strange idea we are talking about different things hmm
  • A Soul's Burden

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    69 Views
    M
    Every good comes from Allah and every bad results from what our own hands have wrought. Allah loves those who put their trust in Him; and who fears taking up the responsibilities upon himself for any goodly rewards. The burden is what we have accumulated on our heads and on our shoulders as our responsibilities with pride, without entrusting them with Allah, The All Knowing, Wise. I could not agree more, o brother. Amen b'Allah
  • The Quran and the 2nd Arab Spring - collaborative article?

    14
    0 Votes
    14 Posts
    81 Views
    I
    The Arab Spring is utter nonsense, in fact, it is the cause of destruction for the Arabs. Look at our beautiful Saudi Arabia which has been saved by Allah from the current crises and corruption that has swept most of the Arab world. That is because there was no "Arab Spring" in Saudi Arabia, Alhamdulillah for that! The Arab spring has effected the following countries 1. Tunisia 2. Egypt 3. Libya 4. Yemen 5. Bahrain 6. Syria All six of these countries are experiencing the worst turmoil. Syria in particular is in the midst of an appalling civil war. Monarchy is in fact the best form of government (and the only viable form of government mentioned in the Qur'an BTW) Democracy is destroying the Arab world and even a lot of the non-Arab Muslim countries. Pakistan is a perfect example. On the other hand, countries like Saudi, Oman, Emirates, Qatar, and Kuwait are the most secure and peaceful places in the entire Muslim world. This is the blessing of Monarchy and Kingdom. The Qur'an commands us to obey Allah, obey His Messenger (which is why we follow Sunnah and Hadith), and those who are in a position of authority. That primarily means the government. Obedience to the government is like an article of faith from the Islamic perspective. Uprising, revolutions, and the like are doomed to failure and invoke the Anger of Allah (Blessed and Most High)
  • Can anyone answer?

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    141 Views
    F
    @Fusion, Salaam, That's what I have decided to learn.
  • Cure To Jinn Possesion

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    24 Views
    M
    Regardless if she believes it's jinn or not, will need psychiatric help to figure out the point of origin. I'm not a professional but spent most of my years growing up figuring out and where possible fixing people's problems. If she's given up on everything else and she's tried everything everyone here has suggested and she's not prepared (or can't afford, Depending on country) psychiatric help then I'm open to talking to her and try and find the root of the problem. Give me a pm if she finds this acceptable.
  • Could an Atheist be a believer.

    117
    0 Votes
    117 Posts
    5k Views
    A
    4915 Believers are those who believe in God and His messenger, then they became without doubt, and they strive with their money and their lives in the cause of God. These are the truthful ones 82 The believers are those whom, when God is mentioned, their hearts reverence; and when His revelations are recited to them, it increases their faith; and they put their trust in their Lord. No way an atheist can be a believer according to the Quran. Both the verses , speak of "Muimin's" as the ones who believe in "Allah" .What if there is an atheist who rejects God , but acknowledges intelligent design , and ultimate consciousness.Can't Allah translate to "The ultimate consciousness?"
  • The Book: With Your Step Towards Your Liberty

    3
    0 Votes
    3 Posts
    9 Views
    R
    Here it is http//www.amazon.com/Your-Step-Towards-Liberty-ebook/dp/B00NUY7NOO/ref=la_B00O905BZ6_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1414642990&sr=1-1 Peace, R.
  • 0 Votes
    2 Posts
    43 Views
    M
    Ultimately advancement only goes as far as one is willing to pay, most scientists in the modern world fulfill private sector needs and conditions, and are paid by such. Its also why most have the end stage of reaching a material product to be sold for profit. Private sector research has its benefits, and probably faster than state sponsored, but fails sometimes in its moral responsibilities. To be fair, most athletes as well only get a portion of their salary by government grants, the vast majority is from advertisement contracts, and few athletes are able to compete at professional level without both.
  • How to destroy atheism without beheading anyone

    16
    0 Votes
    16 Posts
    24 Views
    R
    Merely the fact about the ingenuity of nature I find a great sign of a "higher power" and it was among those reasons I became confident that there is one. I did not become a person of faith due to the pathetic impression of world religions. In fact I was generally always skeptical to them, even when I tried the sectarian "Islam" for a while in my naivety which was my only involvement in 'organized religion'. I try not to blame myself, it is easy to be a bit deluded, but I was never as deluded that I had any faith in narratives like the so-called "hadith of Muhammad". However, I was a person with faith in "God", before I begun to test "Islam" in 2010, without adhering to any 'organized religion'. I consider that I left this delusion in 2013, about three years later, fooled for three years although with suspicions. Now I know the Arabic text does teach something entirely different than the 'organized religion' wants us to think. Salam Man of Faith, My story is same as yours. I didn't see world religions as fully irrelevant, for you know we are already told that all of them came from the same lord, but then got messed up. For a while, I thought our mainstream Islam was perfect, but the more I read hadiths, bibles and talmuds, the more I started feeling suspicious about it. That said, I truly think you have to be the biggest dumb to think that no supreme power exists especially if you go to school, think about the perfection of your body and nature. But I guess some people take the earth for granted, making it difficult for them to think outside the box. I come from a family of medical doctors, chemists and biologists. My dad taught me to believe in evolution when I was a kid. But the more I talked to my relatives and siblings about evolution the more it started to look like a fairy tale. You truly have to go indepth to know the flaws that exist within it. I also read the journal articles from my university database. I am not from science field, but they made me laugh like crazy rotfl. Its pretty much like hadith books if you ask me. I see the story of evolution like a blockbuster sci fi movie. It has all cool make believe actors and ground breaking vfx. You'd love to watch the movie on and on. But if you use logic and read the actual script you will be left with thousands of questions which will later force you to believe that reality is far away from it. Okay, I was teasing Jafar for a while. Now I'll turn serious and burst the bubble. It is usually believed that evolution of one creature turning into another happened slowly. Jafar here also believes the same. He claimed that chimps can have abstract thoughts. Research1 The genetic divergence time between two species varies substantially across the genome, conveying important information about the timing and process of speciation. Here we develop a framework for studying this variation and apply it to about 20 million base pairs of aligned sequence from humans, chimpanzees, gorillas and more distantly related primates. Human-chimpanzee genetic divergence varies from less than 84% to more than 147% of the average, a range of more than 4 million years. Our analysis also shows that human-chimpanzee speciation occurred less than 6.3 million years ago and probably more recently, conflicting with some interpretations of ancient fossils. Most strikingly, chromosome X shows an extremely young genetic divergence time, close to the genome minimum along nearly its entire length. These unexpected features would be explained if the human and chimpanzee lineages initially diverged, then later exchanged genes before separating permanently.http//www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16710306 Conclusion The evolution wasn't slow, but fast and recent. Problem 2 The most comprehensive catalog of great-ape genome diversity to date offers insight into primate evolution, revealing chimpanzees have a much more complex genetic history than humans.http//www.nbcnews.com/science/science-news/chimp-genetic-history-more-complex-humans-f6C10533510 Question Doesn't that make it sound like the apes came from humans? And well ye knew those amongst you who transgressed in the matter of the Sabbath We said to them "Be ye apes, despised and rejected. 002.065 But this doesnt mean we came from fish. It doesnt mean all animals evolved also. Research There is much variation in bacteria. There are many mutations (in fact, evolutionists say that smaller organisms have a faster mutation rate than larger ones17). But they never turn into anything new. They always remain bacteria. Fruit flies are much more complex than already complex single-cell bacteria. Scientists like to study them because a generation (from egg to adult) takes only 9 days. In the lab, fruit flies are studied under every conceivable condition. There is much variation in fruit flies. There are many mutations. But they never turn into anything new. They always remain fruit flies. Many years of study of countless generations of bacteria and fruit flies all over the world shows that evolution is not happening today. http//www.newgeology.us/presentation32.html I won't say evolution doesnt exist at all. It does, but it doesn't create new creatures like some commercialized scientists claim. Truth from evolutionist Francois Jacob, the nobel prize winner Evolution does not produce novelties from scratch. It works on what already exists, either transforming a system to give it new functions or combining several systems to produce a more elaborate one http//www.jesus-is-savior.com/Evolution%20Hoax/Evidences/joke_of_evolution.gif http//www.samuelheller.ch/wp-content/uploads/2008/04/evolution_fishjoke.jpg http//1.bp.blogspot.com/-XwxVu90WhH4/UWmX_O_V-VI/AAAAAAAAAKI/5czgcfBRYvo/s1600/WhaleEvolutionJoke.jpg
  • For the Love of Truth

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    51 Views
    J
    This is what I should hold "Follow the truth or better never existed." Why? Because if I discard the truth, then something dangerous was waiting for me. Muhammad Ibn Idris al-Shafi?I, one of the greatest Islamic Scholar in history, Do you refer to Imam al-Shafi'i? Was he the founder of Shafi'i madhhab? he used to swear that he don?t care whether he speaks the truth or the one he is debating, as long as reaching the truth, it?s more than enough for him. Hmm... Is that wise? Salm.
  • The essence of Divine Guidance

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    122 Views
    D
    Peace All, It has been often repeated that God guides whomever God wills. This notion has bothered me since the first time I read it, as to me, this seems like an unfair selection process that his little to do with humanity's so-called free-will. In addition, it actually contradicts the very idea of free-will at face value. Looking forward to any thoughts on the topic. Peace, Tay Peace, Tay FM Such is the guidance of God, He guides with it whom He pleases of His servants. And if they set-up partners, then all that they had worked would fall away from them. The Proviso Allah has set for His exclusive guidance is given in the red Allah knows what one hides in breasts and what he reveals outwardly; Allah knows what one's mind speaks to him; Allah knows how much of shirk one houses in the depth of his mind; and thus it is His judgment that is Supreme with regard to how purified one is from shirk. Allah guides him who looks up to Him alone solely and soulfully without associating any other guidance other than His. Allah loves him who does not associate through his every walk of life. Salam drfazl
  • Any thoughts about this Quranic article in headcovering

    38
    0 Votes
    38 Posts
    860 Views
    R
    Click on the pic to copy down its link. It was not about Islam. The blog was talking about the fairy tale character.
  • What do you think of WikiIslam's "questions for Qur'anists?"

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    138 Views
    R
    I began feeling suspicious about the site ever since Ismelled negativity in all articles. Later I found them inserting foreign words within verses. Now they use those Quran translation sites and put links back to them. However, they avoid Sahih internation. WikiIslam Debunked The site was started by Ali Sina, the Iranian ex Muslim (propaganda ). However, it looks like Ali Sina is a made up name for a group of fake ex Muslims. They call themselves atheists and human rights activists, but strangely, here and there, the character speaks of how Muslims should be in hell. Point to note, atheists don't believe in afterlife, heaven and hell. Human rights activists don't speak of nuking other humans. But just like feminism, the entire human rights movement has been polluted by fake activists. I went to research more on this character. I come to conclusion that the men behind this character are terrorists. Here is the investigation report on Ali Sina and his WikiIslam Sourcehttp//www.truthexposed.co.uk/who_is_ali_sina.html (Page 1) Developed by a team of individuals who go by the name of Ali Sina. Ali Sina claims to be an ex-muslim who eventually converted to Atheism who now pledges that he is a humanist and upholds the Human Rights. He places a challenge to all muslims to confront him on any of the matters raised on his site and that he will offer a $50,000.00 US Dollars to whoever manages to prove that he is wrong as well as closing down his site. I have personally viewed his website which is full of insults, foul language, spread of hatred, hundreds which go against the Human Rights Act which is constantly used to discredit and abuse Muslims but when quoted to protect them it is viewed as a bad representation of the Act, many knowledgeable individuals debated him and disproved countless allegations raised by Mr. Sina and his followers and yet his website remains open. Was he really a Muslim? Are any of his followers who utilise muslim names and e-mail addresses really muslims? - See our page for How to identify a Muslim Does he really have Arabic knowlege or does he browse other sites written by Muslims and copy the same information? Does he have any real proof or does he base his allegations on word games, twisting the Arabic language to suit his needs and mostly culture which has nothing to do with Islam as the religion? The challenge is obviously just a way to catch peoples attention and is NOT intended to prove anything. Mr. Sina's credibility is always questioned as despite his fabrications he will NOT debate anyone in public, his apologetic excuse for it is that Muslims have a history of terrorism and could easily get to him. We will analyze articles on his site and study his and others various comments in order to deface this cunning person who seeks to deceipt all who are knowlegeable. Frankly he can keep his money as he will be able to enjoy his temporary journey in this life which spans around 60-100 years per average person. Ali Sina's site is obviously a very convincing one, for anyone who has no knowledge or doesn't do his research correctly would fall into his well presented trap. Faith Freedom authors together with Ali Sina have been caught of the following Lying on several occasions Usage of foul language throughout Using comments made by Muslims by editing them to show only the bad side Usage of culture based crimes to somehow point that this is related to Islam. Spreading hatred between all Christians, Jews, Muslims Claiming to uphold Human Rights and yet going against his own principles. Lately publishing his book trying to desperately prove Muhammad (Pbuh) was a terrible person and completely ignoring the fact that many have proven him wrong. So what does Ali Sina think about Islam? He portrays Islam as a menace to society. In an interview at a forum he describes Islam in short by quoting a verse from the Quran. The concept of Islamic peace is expressed in the verse 2.193 of the Quran. And fight them until fitnah is no more, and religion is for Allah. Ali Sina's intent is to brainwash everyone by implementing the belief that Islam was spread by the sword or by forcing people to become Muslims. (He purposely ignores historical proof that Islam ruled half the world and allowed other religions to be practised without forcing anyone). On another forum he wrote the following If any city in the West is nuked I am 100% for nuking tens of cities in Islamic countries.I don't see Muslims as innocent people. They are all guilty as sin. It is not necessary to be part of al Qaida to be guilty. If you are a Muslim you agree with Muhammad and that is enough evidence against you. Page 2 Sourcehttp//www.truthexposed.co.uk/who_is_ali_sina_page2.html In another forum he stated the following I think the world should destroy the Islamic world completely in a way that they can't have any strength to do anything. He wrote a different article which he entitled ?every time I read a Muslim letter I feel like puking?. He constantly boasts about debating with anyone by enlightening them about Islam. on other forums he stated the following comments when debating to a Muslim (Screenshot here) Some of the comments he uses which highlights his level of intellect I have no compassion for stupid people. I know what you would do. You have no Brain. You are Satan worshipper. There is no hope for you. You are destined for hell fire because you are not able to think. You are evil, your prophet was evil and you will go to hell. In another debate he said (Screenshot here) This Muslim (I find the word "Muslim" very derogatory and insulting. It is synonymous to stupid, barbarian, thug, arrogant, brain dead, zombie, hooligan, goon, shameless, savage and many other ignoble things. Ali Sina character is not from Iran at all. He is a pure Israeli who even has connection to terrorist Pamela Geller. His own words reflect what Israelis write at Twitter We love you Muslims because you are humans like us. We are all related to each other. We are all limbs of the body of mankind. But you are diseased. You are infected by a deadly cult that threatens our lives. Your humanity is destroyed. Like a limb infected by flesh eating disease, now you are a threat to the rest of mankind. Islam is disease. What does moderate Muslim mean anyway? Does it mean you are moderately diseased? His connection to terrorists International Activist Leadership Team to be called the SION President?s Council. The initial members of the President?s Council are SIOE?s Anders Gravers; Tommy Robinson and Kevin Carroll of the EDL; Debbie Robinson of the Q Society of Australia, Robert Spencer and Pamela Geller. The members of the newly formed council unanimously voted to elect Pamela Geller Council President. ? The President?s Council differs from the SION Board, which includes Swiss parliamentarian Oskar Freysinger; Cliff Kincaid of Accuracy in Media; Ashraf Rameleh of Voice of the Copts; Ali Sina of FaithFreedom.org; Wafa Sultan, Stefan Herre of Politically Incorrect in Germany; the Israeli author Dr. Mordechai Kedar; Babu Suseelan; and Anders Gravers of SIOE. Sourcehttp//spencerwatch.com/2013/01/15/afdisions-leadership-arrests-scandals/ We all Muslims have been saying that terrorists have no religion. Ali Sina, the wiki islam terrorist is just that. He is probably jewish, but he is more interested in divide and rule. Here we go with his antisemetic and anti christian bigotry. By Ali Sina But there was another element in shaping his character The influence of Rabbis. Judaism and Islam have a lot in common. They have basically the same eschatology and very similar teachings. For example few people know that stoning adulterers that is widely practiced in Islam originates from the Bible. Muhammad did practice stoning but he did not insert it in his Quran. But he said when a law is not clearly stated, Muslims should look into the Bible for guidance. These are all secondary influences of Judaism on Islam. The main common feature between these two faiths is their intolerance. This intolerance in Judaic texts gave the narcissist Muhammad the power to do as he pleased. He could make his claim without needing to prove it and expect others to believe without questioning him. If they didn?t, he would threaten them with hellfire. How could he get away with that? Why would people believed in his unproven and often irrational claims? The answer to this question is in Judaism. The Rabbis in Arabia had laid the psychological foundation for Islam among the tolerant pagans. For 2000 years they had preached that Yahweh, their god, is beyond reason, i.e. he is irrational, that his ways are different and they may appear unjust and even evil. But it is not up to humans to question God?s wisdom. That kind of authority and power is a narcissist?s wet dream. By claiming to be the messenger of God, the same intolerant god of the Jews, Muhammad did not have to prove any of his claims. The reason Arabs fell into his trap was because of the groundwork laid by the Rabbis in Arabia. source http//theamericanmuslim.org/tam.php/features/articles/ali_sina/0018477