Skip to content

Questions/Comments on the Quran

All questions regarding the meaning of words or translation of verses from the Quran are welcome here.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

3.8k Topics 70.3k Posts
  • 22:78 who named us surrender/submitters?

    9
    0 Votes
    9 Posts
    53 Views
    G
    Peace, Thanks Mz, as is your effort with khizir. It is as always a joint effort. I am convinced that together we will find the truth if we seek it with sincere hearts. The great reading is it's own lexicon and tafsir. God has said His deen will prevail. There are many words like Jibril, jabara=powerful, jibril=God's powerful, a common noun.
  • Quran - The reading?

    55
    0 Votes
    55 Posts
    1k Views
    Z
    ayman wrote I think you misunderstood me brother. its seems so...i havent noticed you have reffered to capitalisation.... best wishes, Zlatan
  • Can we touch God?

    11
    0 Votes
    11 Posts
    132 Views
    D
    GONE!
  • adam and alddam ?

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    26 Views
    M
    Salaam Zein, Salaam marie, lol Something that may be of no interest whatsover... Check this connection in swahili; Adam = the first created (human) being Binadamu = human being (general word used) damu = blood Thanks for your reply, may I add this 230 , He announced His Plan to the angels (the Universal physical Laws), ?Behold, I am about to place a creation in the earth that will inherit it.? They exclaimed, ?Will you place on it such creation as will cause disorder therein and shed blood (alddima)! Whereas we strive to establish Your glory in the Universe and make it manifest that You Lord are Impeccable!? He answered, ?Behold, I know that which you know not.? ((1527), (1649-50)). Human evolution ((62), (7189), (225), (2312-13), (2554), (327-9), (3511), (3711), (7117)). 231 Then Allah endowed mankind (Adam) with the capacity to attain knowledge (that the angels would never have). Then He showed the angels certain things and said to them, ?Tell me if you have the capacity to learn about things in the Universe, in case what you say is true.? (That this new creation is but vain). It is astonishing that Adam sons (human) are predisposed to shed blood (alddima) before their etablissemnt on earth twisted
  • Location of the messengers and revelations

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    46 Views
    D
    "How many a sign in the heavens and on the earth and between them! They pass by them all, unmindful!" Messengers are every where around now in all languages, in all nations, in all communities, in all tribes, in all towns and in all individuals, all over the world! Now!!
  • Who are Children of Israel?

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    117 Views
    D
    Children of israel are those who are entrusted with intelligence a little above over the other people by god, as only a test for them in this world. God knew they were the people who shall be proud and arrogant and involve in destruction and transgression. The choice is theirs either they be humble and be grateful for what allah had granted; or, indulge in inflicting the world communities with excesses using their 'testy-intelligence'. God has chosen the children of israel from the rest of the people of the world communities as a warning and remind. God will choose amongst you, the rest of the tribes/communities too! When He endows you with the wisdom a little above the rest of the people of your tribe/community, please mind "You're the chosen ones from the rest, for the test!" So be not fallen people like the israelites, then! If you fall, you are chosen people for the hell, like the israelites of today!
  • "muslim" is it submitter or peacful one?

    12
    0 Votes
    12 Posts
    20 Views
    D
    (320) ...And say to those who were given The Book and the gentiles,"Do you submit/surrender?" ... What should the ending be, based on the conclusions we came to above? 003 . 020 And if they argue with thee, say I have accepted whole heartedly my purpose to Allah and those who follow me. And say unto those who have received the Scripture and those who had not received the scripture "Have ye accepted?" If they accept, then truly they are rightly guided, and if they turn away, then it is thy duty only to convey the message. Allah is Seer of bondmen. The end result is guidance to the right path; free from adversities and afflictions in life.
  • Submission.Org Responds To Article About Theft Punishment

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    37 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you, What happenned to "cutting the control" of the thief, which sounds like imprisonment, where you have no control anymore.
  • Who was the first Muslim?

    8
    0 Votes
    8 Posts
    125 Views
    D
    Hasten towards good to be the first among the firsts! He who drops his ego first, is the first amongst the muslims of his people!
  • CAN WE SEE GOD?

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    60 Views
    D
    You can only feel Him as close as possible even nearer than your life vein
  • SALAM : NEVER SAY

    51
    0 Votes
    51 Posts
    955 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you Doctor, Ihave nothing urther to say regarding the greeting of PEACE. Regarding seeing and knowledge, this discussion is going on in many other threads, so I desgibned the thread "knowledge vs. wisdom" for those discussions. I am done here, PEACE to all.
  • Isa is the prophet ; Jesus is not

    103
    0 Votes
    103 Posts
    2k Views
    U
    Peace be upon you Doctor, idolfree1 wrote Peace be upon you Doc, Okay, so now tell us why the God tells us to SAY "My Lord, increase my knowledge". With the negativity you have associated with knowledge, why does the God tell us to seek increase in it? Help me understand. Doctor Your translation of ILM is knowledge, whereas the meaning is "ability to understand the TRUTH". When you seek knowledge from Allah, it means you want the truth from allah/the absolute understanding/the Wisdom. "O Lord Increase my ability to understand the Truth" You understand TRUTH by knowing, and proper application of that KNOWING is Wisdom. Doctor, it appears that you have taken on Man's corruption of the word "KNOWledge" as your correct definition. The better metod would be to bring back the correct understanding of that word, then you will remove the difficulty you have in translating "Ilm" to Knowledge.
  • 9:18 WHO SHALL REPAIR THE MOSQUE?

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    35 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you, Yes, even more proof that "masjid" is not physical.
  • An Interesting Traditional View on Al-Kitab

    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    23 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you Idris, do you have any links to sites about the Kemetans, their teachings, civilization, technology, etc.? http//www.africawithin.com/black_history/overview_chapter16.html http//www.sfbayview.com/090104/africanroots090104.shtml http//www.nbufront.org/html/MastersMuseums/JHClarke/ArticlesEssays/WhyAfricanaHistory.html http//www.nathanielturner.com/notoutofgreecereview.htm The above are a few sites that mention that Greeks learned from Kemet. But the best I can do is refer you to the following books "Not out of Greece" by Ra Un Nefer Amen "Nile Valley contributions to civilization" by Anthony T Browder Other authors are John Henrik Clarke, Chieck Anta Diop, Naim Akbar. Regarding the spiritual philosophy , I recommend "Metu Neter Vol 1 & 2" by Ra Un Nefer Amen I highly recommend all of the above books and authors. HIGHLY! Lastly, I recommend to everyone to read the metaphoric story of Ausar(Osirus), it is the oldest known metaphoric story and contains a great deal of wisdom and "familiar" themes.
  • Iman Mumin Muslim

    40
    0 Votes
    40 Posts
    505 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you Doctor, Please be direct and hold us no longer in limbo, WHY does the God advise us to seek INCREASE in knowledge? Yet you tell us to reject knowledge? We recognize the superiority of Wisdom over Knowledge, but how do you come to th econclusion that knowledge is wicked and should be rejected? How do you even read these posts without knowledge of alphabet?
  • Seven Universes

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    77 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you Green Leaves, Quote First off, your avatar makes me "feel" very at peace Cant explain why. I am a closet photographer and I take several pics in my backyard or when I am traveling...not sure if this one is my work or if I got it elsewhere online, but I am glad you like it To me, it reminds me of California where every season its green and beautiful! Keep up the good work. What we SEE has the most effect on us as the EYE is our most powerful sense. Now to the question Quote Anyway, The God says that there are 7 skies and the earth. Regarding beings living out there, I have no knowledge of that but I would not be suprised if there were. But, the verse says seven universes and clearly points out seven earths, right? I am not so sure, that would seem to contradict because the God has told us many times about the earth and the seven skies, He does not speak about the 7 earths and 7 skies, only the earth and 7 skies. It is only when we get to this verse that the translators have given us this idea. When I look further, this is what I found. (6512) God is who created seven skies, and from the earth equal/similar to them (mithlahunna)... This word "mithlahunna" looks to me to be related to the word used throughout to denote SYMBOLISM/Similitudes. So if that is correct, what I think is being said is that the seven skies are similar to the one earth, or as I said in my last post, the 7 skies are what effect the earth, or in other words, the 7 spheres of our spirit/mind effect our PERSON. The physical earth is certainly under the influecne of the objects in the skies. I was reading the description of this verse on Submission.org's website and they've said that there are seven other universes out there just like ours; each containing a Mercury, Venus, Earth... This (according to them) is God's proof to the evolutionists on the Day that the Earth and human life simply did not evolve without a Creator from a single cell, but was created and that God can effortlessly create as many universes as God wants....which kind of makes sense. Now, say this is true hypothetically and we know that God doesn't make anything without a purpose...could there be humans living in each of those seven earths out there? The fact that submission.org, or no one else, has been throughout the universe, we cannot say there are Seven other "universes". In fact, the word UNIverse, implies only ONE (UNI). Perhaps they meant 7 other galaxies or solar systems, but whatever the case, there is NO WAY thaey can know if there are only 7 more as oppossed to a billion more, we just cannot see that far. WHile it is interesting science, and I would be interested to know the TRUTH of that, it is not top priority to the God's message because He did not speak of any beings in outer space. Also, the many generations that past have lived and dies without that question being answered, I am fine also with not knowing that. If we find out that there are beings in space, I hope that the Earth beings don't corrupt them as they do thier fellow earth beings. I hope thye don't enslave them and make them work for no pay, or keep them homeless, or prostitutre them, or tax them with all kinds of taxes to oppress them unfairly, etc.
  • An interesting contrast...K-F-R vs Sh-K-R

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    10 Views
    U
    Peace be upon you Ash Shura, What occurred to me is that Kaf-Fa-Ra (Kufr) seems to be the antonym to Sha-Kaf-Ra (Shukr). Hence, Shukr is given by doing the reverse of Kufr, following GODs injunctions, doing good deeds. You know as opposed to sitting on our butts and saying shukran shukran So simple and clear isnt it? It is about ACTION, not lip service. We thank the God by doing what we are asked to do. It sounds so simple, yet so many are unaware of this simple fact. Most are too busy "wroshiping" some object called "god", instead of SERVING the ONENESS which is the God.
  • I am unclear on this verse

    19
    0 Votes
    19 Posts
    310 Views
    D
    All of you give importance with earnestness to the grammar/dictionary meanings to start wiith, then soon you go for interpretation/context leaving the language/dictionary/meanings/gramar in the lurch. Contrasting difference of opinions, finally each sticking to his own understanding is enough evidence from Allah that we stopped groping about grammar and dictionary to understand an ayat of Allah. Let us use commonsense that has become very uncommon.
  • Shahr/month in the light of the quran

    163
    0 Votes
    163 Posts
    4k Views
    O
    Peace, Just a thought that came to mind. In the verse it says Faman shahad menkom al-shahr ..... does that mean some will not witness that month only because of death, or is it possible as well not to witness the month for other reasons?
  • 2:217 what is disbelief?

    8
    0 Votes
    8 Posts
    126 Views
    H
    Peace hlatif So in 10.87 It says make the house a DIRECTION/DIRECTION of ACCEPTANCE. This may mean open your houses to whoever wants to make a good deed for the sake of GOD. Prayer is one of them. (I do not want to comment on this interpretation) Abdullah Yousuf Ali's Commentary on 1087 This instruction, WE MAY SUPPOSE, was given when the sorcerers were brought to confusion, and some of the Egyptians believed. Moses for a little while to remain in Egypt, so that his Message should have time to work, before the Israelites were led out of Egypt. THEY WERE TO MAKE THEIR HOUSES INTO PLACE OF PRAYER (QIBLAH), as Pharaoh would NOT probably ALLOW them to SET UP PUBLIC PLACES OF PRAYER. Read the interpretations of all the translators, you will find each of them contradicting the other. WHY? It is not righteousness that ye turn your faces Towards east OR West; but it is righteousness- to BELIEVE in Allah and the Last Day, and the Angels, and the Book, and the Messengers; TO SPEND of your substance, out of love for Him, for your kin, for orphans, for the needy, for the wayfarer, for those who ask, and for the ransom of slaves; TO BE steadfast in prayer, and PRACTICE regular charity; TO FULFILL the contracts which YOU HAVE MADE; and to be firm and patient, in pain (or suffering) and adversity, and throughout all periods of panic. Such are the people of truth, the Allah-fearing. 2177 Traditional translations are miles away from perfection. It is not righteousness that you turn your faces to the East (WA) AND the West; but righteous is he who (AAMANA) BELIEVED in Allah and the Last Day and the angels and the Scripture and the Prophets; and (AATAA) GAVE his wealth, for love of Him, to kinsfolk and to orphans and the needy and the wayfarer and to those who ask, and to set slaves free; and (AQAAMA) ESTABLISHED the PRAYERS and (AATAA) GAVE the ZAKAAT, and (MOFON) HONORED his covenant when he covenanted, and the patient in tribulation and adversity and time of stress. Such are they who are sincere. Such are the God fearing. 2177 He who BELIEVED in Allah, the Last day, the angels, the scriptures, and the Prophets He who GAVE away his wealth to the poor etc. (what remains with him so that he can give ZAKAAT and to WHOM?) (Is there any verse, which says GIVE ZAKAT to THE POOR etc.) He who GAVE Zakaat? How much? (It is an on going process, continues till death) He who OFFERED his PRAYERS? How many times / days / weeks / years (this is on going process, continues till death) Has Allah explained the minimum requirements of GIVING ZAKAAT and OFFERING PRAYERS, to make an individual eligible for the post of RIGHTEOUS and GOD FEARING? What you understood when Allah said " he who GAVE away his wealth to the poor, he who GAVE zakaat, he who OFFERED prayers, IS RIGHTEOUS AND GOD FEARING? Surely, the TERRORISTS and the Afghan OPIUM producers, who give their wealth to the poor, who give zakaat, who pray more than five times (daily five + chaasht and Ishraq) are RIGHTEOUS and GOD FEARING? Think about them in the light of the verse 2177 'INNA-MAA YAcMUR MASAAJID 'ALLAAH MAN 'AAMANA BI- 'ALLAAH WA- AL- YAWM AL- 'AAKHIR WA- AQAAMA AS.- S.ALAAH WA- 'AATAA AZ- ZAKAAH WA- LAM YAKHSHA 'ILLAA 'ALLAAH FA- cASAA 'OLAA'IKA 'AN YAKONO MIN AL- MUHTADEN 918 The mosques of Allah shall be maintained by such as (AAMANA) BELIEVED in Allah and the Last Day (AQAAMA) ESTABLISHED the PRAYERS and (AATAA) GAVE the ZAKAAT and fear none (at all) except Allah. It is they who are expected to be on true guidance. 918 WHY ALLAH HAS NOT ORDERED THE BELIEVERS TO MAINTAIN THE MOSQUE? WHY ALLAH HAS SET, SUCH HIGH STANDARD OF FAITH, FOR JUST MAINTENANCE OF THE MOSQUE. WHY ONLY THOSE WHO HAVE BELIEVED, AND ESTABLISHED THE PRAYERS (HOW MANY TIMES / DAYS / WEEKS / YEARS, NOT MENTIONED?) WHY ONLY THOSE WHO GAVE ZAKAAT, HOW MUCH, NOT MENTIONED) (What relation has ZAKAAT with the repairing of the Mosque?) WHY ONLY THOSE WHO FEAR ALLAH ONLY? WHO ARE THOSE WHO FEAR ALLAH ONLY? Those who CONVEY / PREACH the Message of Allah and FEAR Him, and FEAR NONE EXCEPT ALLAH. And Sufficient is Allah as a Reckoner. 3339 WA- MIN AN- NAAS WA- AD- DAWAAB WA- AL- ANcAAM MUKHTALIF ALWAAN -HU KA- DHAALIKA 'INNA-MAA YAKHSHAA 'ALLAAH MIN cIBAAD -HI AL- cULAMAA' 'INNA 'ALLAAH cAZEZ GHAFOR 3528 And of men, and beasts, and cattle, likewise of diverse colours. IT IS ONLY THOSE WHO ARE (cULAMAA) LEARNED / SCHOLAR among his slaves THAT FEAR ALLAH. Verily Allah is the Mighty, the Forgiving. 3528 So according to Allah only THOSE WHO PREACH / CONVEY the message of ALLAH and THOSE WHO ARE cULMAA (LEARNED / SCHOLAR) are ELIGIBLE CANDIDATES FOR THE MAINTENANCE OR REPAIRING OF THE MOSQUE. Thanks