Skip to content

Questions/Comments on the Quran

All questions regarding the meaning of words or translation of verses from the Quran are welcome here.

This category can be followed from the open social web via the handle [email protected]

3.8k Topics 70.2k Posts
  • An Critic on Qur'anic Ayats

    20
    0 Votes
    20 Posts
    299 Views
    The_SardarT
    Salam imran, i wonder if you have seen this http//quranscientificerror.blogspot.com/2013/06/re-different-seas-have-impenetrable.html
  • Role and function of Prepositions

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    12 Views
    M
    I reply to you for this request (in red above and i justified by giving a proof) "Any views about the role and function of prepositions in the text of Qur'an starting with this preposition. Arabic is a spoken language. It is a language where meanings are embedded in a syllable smallest of which comprises of a consonant and a vowel, like بـِ a prefixed preposition (Part of speech Particle)
  • A.L.M...single letters and "strike your wifes?" (4:34)

    4
    0 Votes
    4 Posts
    10 Views
    M
    What is the outcome of all this exercise?
  • (87:7) and rhetorical analysis

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    10 Views
    I
    Not knowing story, we tell stories and that ends up making stories
  • 0 Votes
    16 Posts
    191 Views
    N
    Nothing can help when man decided to shut all passages to brain. When a child is born he is not called Man. وَنُقِرُّ فِى ٱلۡأَرْحَامِ مَا نَشَآءُ إِلَـىٰٓ أَجَلٛ مُّسَمّٙى And We implant-make those reside in the wombs whom Our Majesty so will, towards a determined length of time with appointed termination moment. ثُـمَّ نُخْرِجُكُـمْ طِفْلٙا Afterwards the lapse of appointed duration Our Majesty discharge you as an infant. ثُـمَّ لِتَبْلُغُوٓا۟ أَشُدَّكُمْۚ Afterwards, Our Majesty keep developing you to cross over to your strengthen maturity. It is useless talking any more to you. Stay blessed. Thank you brother. May Allah SWT bless you as well.
  • Christian Prince attacking Quran

    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    15 Views
    C
    The guys arabic skill is questionable, there is a muslim named Mokhtar Benchohra responds to this "Christian Prince" https//www.youtube.com/watch?v=CiQMqJjB3MM https//www.youtube.com/channel/UC_dWbXyfpJKIUJAKcUwQZTA Thank you Bro Sardar, I will check it out God bless you all
  • understanding BaGhA'a in 24:33 and in 19:20 and Tahasanun

    17
    0 Votes
    17 Posts
    151 Views
    M
    Root Words from this Root in the Grand Qur?n a) Total occurrences 96 b) No of constructions 51 It occurs in 89 Ayahs in 41 Sura Nouns 13' Recurrence 31; Verbs 38 Recurrence 65 Ibn Faris stated ( &#1577 . That it signifies firstly the demand, seeking a thing/object; and secondly it signifies some sort of corruption, degeneration, transgression. perversion, immorality, and turpitude. Lane Lexicon He sought; sought for, or after; sought, desired, or endeavoured, to find, and take, Semantic domain Emotion Sub field Seeking http//haqeeqat.pk/roots/(12.htm
  • Qur'an version question

    12
    0 Votes
    12 Posts
    21 Views
    G
    Peace NJada. The following may answer some of your questions On peaceful mind( Muslim to GOD) Love GOD the most Eventually, when your mind is healed/freed/at peace, you will feel completely free from hate, Jealousy, gossip, anger, tit for tat chat, revenge,?etc Your mind will be lifted by GOD towards bliss to encounter love towards GOD Alone, then it will resonate/translate this love towards all His creatures. Love your neighbour What a wonderful feeling. All around you will start to benefit from the new you, your family, friends ,enemies and yourself of course. You will find the purpose of your life is independent of all others, only dependent on your creator. You will start to concentrate on your thoughts and actions ,trying your best to do to others what you would like to see done to you. All people will be as though they are your family ( Your Mum, Dad, Brother, Sister, Uncle, Aunt?). Of course ,as a human, there will be moments when we step out of GOD s realm, GOD then will give you a push back as a reminder. Acknowledging ,repenting and going back to the realm will save you again and so on?. Or take no notice if you wish to remain independent of GOD, but the disease will take over again. Muslim to GOD is a ?great jihad? against oneself only, if only each one of us realises and takes up this special and private relationship with GOD Alone. The true feeling of happiness On all other sects/religions I am sure with all our differences ,providing we accept each other as we are, there must be hope that at least we can live in peace with each other. So what if your fellow human went to a synagogue, or prayed in a church, or went to a temple or did a congregation prayer behind a man or a woman or? . If they stop their wars, aggression, lording it above each other, fighting each other, hating each other, gossiping ,backbiting, ridiculing, claiming their religion is the truth?etc You never know, just may be , now or in 100 years or so? GOD Alone will unite them? On priorities The number one priority ,the top of any list must be the uniting factor-GOD Alone,our Creator, all of us humans- Now, GOD places Justice, fairness and good intentions as the most important part of His system. We seem to always concentrate on the trivial matters that are personal and can be overlooked by GOD if we have the right intentions. Among the many books of religions out there, very few deal with the subject of ?justice, fairness and good intentions ?i.e the attitude of our mind towards GOD s system to keep the balance for all GOD s creatures. The most important useful analysis for any human including ?Muslims? is to deal with this utmost priority, the attitude of mind towards the one GOD and His just system must be top of the list. Everything else will then follow with GOD s guidance and trust. My thoughts .If you still have more questions, I am happy to discuss. GOD bless you. Peace.
  • Simple Question in regards to the Monotheist Translation

    6
    0 Votes
    6 Posts
    64 Views
    I
    Does the monotheist translation of the Qur'an have any commentary documented somewhere outside the official pdf that if I realy wanted the commentary, I could have? Its mean you are reading the mind of commentator and solely relied/dependant on his/her information. author of quran suggest to read QURAN slowly and take your time and abilities provided to you for the great reading by yourself (1736). by this method you will feel urself more polished and blessed with confidence in hand. God bless you
  • Question on Fasting

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    26 Views
    I
    Where are you absorbed dear. I mean the timings I mentioned, they are before start and after end of Fast. Sorry but quran doesn't mention " medication". In your understanding of these ayats if you are ill you don't need to "fast" (siyam or sawm or the same for you ?). Simple. another crazy question if fast means to "prohibite of eat and drink and sex.." during the DAY time (sun is visible) what does means the "NIGHT of fast" in 2187 ?
  • Question on Fasting time

    9
    0 Votes
    9 Posts
    19 Views
    M
    Salam to All, So it can be said night (layl) starts at Nautical twilight if I understood you correctly God bless No, Night starts http//haqeeqat.pk/English%20Tafsir%20e%20Haqeeqat/00.Arabic%20Text/017.%20Al%20Israa/17.78.gif The verbal noun signifies a state of rubbing and getting away with ease and smoothly. The Sun touches/rubs the horizon and smoothly disappears whereby the night emerges. http//haqeeqat.pk/SalatTimings.htm
  • Marriage Jews and Christians

    7
    0 Votes
    7 Posts
    13 Views
    H
    The point is not that, the point is what makes you in that aya to conclude that people of the book are not legitimate for marriage by muslim women. Answer that first and then the rest falls into place. Salaam
  • 87:19 = What are "The scripts of Abraham and Moses" ?

    12
    0 Votes
    12 Posts
    20 Views
    M
    Salam Mazhar, Suhuf as Papyrus is an interpretation. Suhuf means first as a SUPPORT for something writed. It is better to translate as Leaf, sheet, page.. In the quran the root of the word suhuf has the following meaning 4371 = Plates 8110 = a support where all our actions are written Others = Physical Leaf/sheet specially support for divine truth Muhammad recited from "suhuf" in 982 (only find in Egypta ??) and in Medina Jews have also "suhuf".. 982 A messenger from Allah reciting pages/leaf purified.. Look at sura 5336 => (sorry google translation) Has he with him the knowledge of the occult so that he sees? Have they not been informed of what was in the pages of Moses? and Abraham, who was rewarded? Let no burden bearer carry the burden of another, and that man only gets the fruit of his efforts, and that his effort will soon be visible, Then he will be rewarded with a complete reward - and the final term is to your Lord, => Again this themes can be finding in "apocrypha" not in the Torah.. But again you, like me, canno't be sure... No end for a meaningless wrangling. Page means one or both sides of a sheet of paper in a book.
  • what are the clear proofs in quran?

    8
    0 Votes
    8 Posts
    79 Views
    M
    What are these proofs? soundness https//scontent.fkul1-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/58549519_2329462503936994_7252043908404740096_n.jpg?_nc_cat=105&_nc_ht=scontent.fkul1-1.fna&oh=80dd847b1187d13e40b883110966bc2b&oe=5D3801AC Have iman in • Allah (MATH / Validity / Law of Nature or Sunnatullah) • AND His Messenger (E / Truth / Natural Person or Society) • AND in the Light (ISM / Soundness / Natural Law or "Islam&quot. (Q64 8 ) But as for those who have • clear evidence from their LordLaw 12 (of Nature or The Universe/Sunnatullah/Way of Allah Validity) • followed up by a witness 6940 from Him (Revelation/Natural Person Truth) • and before it the ordain of Musa came as a model and a mercy 7156-157 (Tawba/Natural Law Soundness) such people have iman in it (Quran - "what are the clear proofs in quran?&quot. Any faction which rejects it (three conditions above) is promised the Fire. Be in no doubt about it. It is the Truth (proof) from your Lord. But many people have no iman. (Q1117) 4083 When their Messengers brought them the Clear Signs, they exulted in the knowledge they had and then were engulfed by the very things they mocked. When they saw Our violent force, they said, "We have iman in Allah/Sunnatullah alone and reject what we associated with Him." But when they saw Our violent force their iman was of no use to them. This is the sunnatullah of Allah established upon His servants for ages! Thereupon those who denied the knowledge of the reality are in loss! (Q4083-85) ~ Sunnatullah Alone Muslim
  • Garry Wills and the Q'uran

    2
    0 Votes
    2 Posts
    34 Views
    The_SardarT
    Is it alright that i can see the note?
  • Wife beating in islam? The Quran strikes back

    301
    0 Votes
    301 Posts
    21k Views
    A
    excellent work! peace! Thank you.
  • Ma Malakat Aymanukum and ?oaths?

    28
    0 Votes
    28 Posts
    102 Views
    M
    Do you believe in some of the Book and reject the rest? (Q285) ok tried being civil only way to deal with dumb spammers with diarrhea. 2433 والذىن and the ones (does not pertain to no wali � you illiterate!) فكاتبوهم so write ye them (i.e. those under your care not no wali � you ignorant!) ان if علمتم know you فىهم in them خىرا goodness of واتوهم and gives ye them (again not no wali � dumb shit!) من from مال wealth Lastly fuck off kill yourself � you fucking madhi/moron! How does that prove the slavegirl can enter into marriage contract without the bride's wali (male / masculine)? How can the bride's wali be female when men are always being responsible/accountable for women (guardian)? To whom you ask for marriage? you may marry slavegirls who are muminun ... Marry them with their owners' permission and give them their dowries ... (425) the fatwa from pseudo-scholars are truly retarded .. The Arabs say, "We have iman." Say "You do not have iman." (Q4914) The Arabs (الْأَعْرَابُ) are the worst in rejection and hypocrisy, and more likely not to know "Islam". (Q997) Arabs and how they read the Quran.. . rotfl
  • rhetoric analysis : Does Isa is among the wicked ? (5:45-46)

    9
    0 Votes
    9 Posts
    15 Views
    M
    Why so insecure? I'm only asking you to justify how "the structuring and organization of the text" or grammar alone is compatible with the Quran.. is that too much to ask? rotfl
  • Verse (18:86) : What is setting place of sun?

    13
    0 Votes
    13 Posts
    168 Views
    A
    China wall is not of iron and copper. Right, brother. The whole present wall of China, would not be the one built in Zulqarnain's era. May be a small part of it was initiated by Zalqarnain, which may be later built upon and extended by subsequent nations. The original part of the wall may have iron reinforcement inside present day bricks and stones. Allah knows best.
  • Stupid is, AS STUPID DOES <- PROOF FOR STUPIDITY

    5
    0 Votes
    5 Posts
    84 Views
    M
    http//haqeeqat.pk/Human%20being.htm In Arabic the semantic frame Creation is embedded in Root خ ل ق. Ibn Faris in his famous lexicon مقاييس اللغة stated about this Root الخاء واللام والقاف أصلان أحدهما تقدير الشيء، والآخر مَلاسَة الشيء That it signifies the act of determining the measures and proportionality of a thing to other things, and then smoothening of the object. Its general perception and meanings as creation are well known. The basic perception is that of the idea and intention of giving existence to the intended object. Thus the thing is created and exists firstly in Abstract Realm before it takes existence in the Physical Realm. The words that stem from this Root are result oriented. The irreducible semantic features of this Root are (1) A living Who is the creator of the object; (2) The will - decision taken by the living to create; (3) The purpose the Creator has in mind to create the object; (4) For what or for whom it is meant; (5) Idea - blue print - determination of measures and proportionality of the thing to other things that creates interrelationships before the object takes existence; (6) The span of time it will continue to exist or live. (7) Assigning a name to the object for its cognition. The first occurrence of the word "creation" is about Man's creation, reflecting the honour he has in the physical realm, though he was made to emerge in physical form when all arrangements commensurate to his status and security were set in place This is خ ل ق https//scontent.fkul7-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/34318282_2109835465899700_7710964505466896384_n.jpg?_nc_cat=107&_nc_ht=scontent.fkul7-1.fna&oh=ed986fef4cee0f91760ef77d6d99f91b&oe=5CD47E9C https//i.pinimg.com/originals/b4/b8/ca/b4b8caf5461c6bc0873167596bd319ec.jpg https//kaiserscience.files.wordpress.com/2015/03/all-in-one-ecosystem-from-atom-to-biosphere.jpg Allah is ENERGY The life of this world is only an illusion. (Quran 5720) https//scontent.fkul1-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/50632863_2275028659380379_964944117639413760_n.jpg?_nc_cat=107&_nc_ht=scontent.fkul1-1.fna&oh=438893bc440cf9d0800ecc340e04c6ae&oe=5CC46BE4